Happy 21st birthday, UNC

Ex-Judge responds to PM, calls Manning a tyrant

Herbert Volney says it was a tough call to make but he felt compelled to quit his job as a judge to defend the rights of the people.

Volney said that is why he decided to enter politics. The ex-judge is the United National Congress (UNC) candidate for St Joseph. UNC leader Kamla Persad-Bissessar announced his candidacy on Wednesday night at a political meeting in San Juan.

Volney said one principal reason for his move was what he termed the interference of Attorney General John Jeremie in the affairs of the Judiciary, and the emergence of Prime Minister Patrick manning as "a dangerous, self-absorbed tyrant".

Volney said he is at peace with what he has done.

Volney made his comments at the UNC's headquarters and spoke from a prepared statement. He was accompanied by former St Joseph MP and UNC minister, Carlos John, the brother of former Appeal Court judge, Stanley John.

"I felt compelled to leave behind a career to assist in the process of delivering Trinidad and Tobago from the crisis it faces today.

"Each day, over the last almost 16 years, I sat on the bench I stared into the eye of evil as cases of the basest kind were brought me...My only fear is the fear of God. I fear no man.

"What is ironic is that the independence of the Judiciary should be held up as one of the criticisms of my decision when that is precisely one of the very reasons I took the decision to leave and play a part in ensuring there is a change in the political directorate," he said.

Volney spoke about how Jeremie attempted to influence the Judiciary. "The former Director of Public Prosecutions, you would recall, recounted the circumstances in which the Attorney General sought to interfere with his independence and attempted to press him into advancing what he believed to be a political agenda," he said. The other, he said, was the "hounding" of former chief justice Satnarine Sharma.

Volney said he stood up for Sharma. And he stood up for former Chief Justice Michael de la Bastide who was at one time in a tussle with UNC Attorney General, Ramesh L. Maharaj.

Speaking about his future role, Volney said he will now seek to help the people from Parliament and pledged to "defend Trinidad and Tobago with the same fervour, fearlessness and fairness that I exercise each day of my life in the many years I served the Judiciary and the nation."

He added, "I have taken a stand for my country because I was left with no other choice. I am confident that history will vindicate my decision."

Judge did nothing wrong: Kamla

Kamla Persad-Bissessar is defending the right of Herbert Volney to leave his job as a judge and run as a candidate for the United National Congress (UNC) in the May 24 general election.

Volney's decision has sparked a storm with both Prime Minister Patrick Manning and the Chief Justice suggesting that it was wrong.

Read the story: Manning suggests UNC interfered in independence of Judiciary
Read the story: CJ says Judge must not "entertain" private discussion with political party

Speaking with reporters at the Reinzi Complex Thursday, the UNC leader said Volney was within his constitutional rights to have a political view. And she noted he expressed his views only after he quit.

She also spoke of other circumstances where judges have had political connections.

"I remember Justice Lucky was offered as a People’s National Movement (PNM) candidate for president while he was a sitting judge. He did not resign and he went back, if I recall, to serve on the bench.

"But I am not saying because you did it, we are doing it. That’s not my point. My point is it is within the constitutional right of the judge," she said.

The UNC leader also had a question for Manning based on a statement he made on the political platform that suggested he knows what judges are thinking.

"Several questions arose to statements made by Mr Manning. He speaks about judges rejoicing, how does he know that? Is he speaking to judges too?" she asked.

Persad-Bissessar admitted that Volney is not a member of the party and that the UNC constitution states that a person must be a financial member of the party for at least one year before he can offer himself as a candidate.

She referred reporters to the case of Ramesh Lawrence Maharaj and others vs the United National Congress in 2001 about the use of the party's symbol, noting that the High Court took "the firm view that the party was in its rights" to send the names of candidates to the Elections and Boundaries Commission (EBC).

She said it is not for the EBC to interpret the party’s constitution "and that judgment was upheld by the Court of Appeal."

Letter: Volney is not Lucky

Different strokes for different folks?

Herbert Volney has been offered an opportunity to be accepted or rejected by the electorate, at the risk of long term unemployment. His judgments have not been appealed.

Sitting Judge AnthonyLucky was offered the highest office in the land while secure in his position without risk. No questions were asked about his judgments in favour of the PNM government. How many of his judgments were overturned upon appeal?

Senior Lawyers routinely serve as fully empowered and obligated temporary judges and return to private practice unrestricted. Volney is being criticised for his act of bravery.

Serial accusations were levelled against Calder Hart who even now remains shielded by the PNM Government. Yet, investigations are allegedly underway to probe Volney for unsubstantiated accusations by persons unnamed.

What is sauce for the PNM goose is exclusive.

It is revelatory that Manning charged quite clearly that Volney may have given Judgements against the Republic of the PNM! This was an inspired blunder to self destruction.

If Judges are so distant from the welfare of the people that they stifle their political consciences and care nothing for their suffering, then there would be no more judges contemplating resignation.

But Judges have families that suffer from government malfeasance. Volney has pioneered a blazing trail.

Volney had recently applied for a Judicial position overseas. His disgust of the PNM administration was legend. His alternative choice is a blessing for T&T.

Destiny is playing its hand in the affairs of this land.

M.F. Rahman - via email.

PNM rejects Penny Beckles a second time

Pennelope Beckles was the MP for Arima in the last Parliament and the Deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives.

So many thought it was a given that she would be chosen again to run in Arima; they were wrong.

The PNM screening committee decided it wanted "a youth" for the constituency and chose former Senator Laurel Lezama, daugher-in-law of top PNM adviser and media boss Louis Lee Sing.

That didn't go down well, but PNMites said they were willing to work with the newcomer.

Then, when the selected candidate for the La Horquetta/Talparo constituency had to drop out because she has dual citizenship and is therefore not qualified to stand, Beckles made another attempt to get in.

The Constituency asked her to stand for nomination and she showed up a Balisier House seeking the nomination for the seat, but at the end of the process the party again rejected Beckles, choosing instead Nadra Nathai-Gyan.

She ran unsuccessfully in St Augustine in the 2007 and was defeated by the UNC's Vasant Bharath.

Last week the PNM screened Nathai-Gyan for the St Ann’s East seat but handed it to another candidate.

The party has had a rough time selecting 41 candidates and faced protests from several areas about the manner in which it chose representatives. Some prospective candidates were rejected despite strong support and others just dropped out.

At least one other had to go because of the dual citizenship issue, another didn't want to give up his job to run for the party and cabinet minister Peter Taylor bowed out after constituents told him they didn't want him.

The party’s central executive has the final say on who will contest the May 24 election and all the candidates in the lineup so far are considered "provisional" until their selection is ratified by the central executive.

Keith Rowley was forced to cancel the launch of his campaign in Diego Martin West Thursday night because the party said his candidacy was not formal and therefore he was not authorised to hold such a meeting.

It's not even clear if he will be the candidate and if he is there is still the question about whether he will speak on the PNM national platform.

The party hopes to complete its selection process by Friday in time for its presentation of the full slate at a rally in Woodford Square on Sunday.

The opposition will make its presentation of candidates on Sunday as well at a rally at the Mid Centre Mall, Chaguanas.

African group slams Manning for Dashiki talk

Patrick Manning has scoffed at the opposition People's Partnership and its inclusion of social activist Makandaal Daaga, suggesting that Daaga is irrelevant to today's politics.

He even took issue with the fact that the leader of the 1970s uprising still wears a Dashiki, saying he could not remember the last time he saw a Dashiki in the country.

But he himself wears the African garment and his comments have offended the Emancipation Support Committee, which has called on Manning and other politicians to be respectful of "all cultures in our multiracial society".

In a media release, the committee said it accepts that political picong is "an ingrained trait of all parties contesting elections, but people’s cultural expressions have to be respected."

The committee said Manning contradicted himself since he "often wears African garments at commemorative activities of African emancipation."

It said Manning's comment is offensive to many persons in the society and across all party lines, adding that it "can open the floodgates to other expressions of cultural contempt which can mar the elections’ environment."

It added, "It can also send a negative signal to Africans, with whom the country is trying to strengthen cultural and economic relationships at the state and non-governmental levels."

The group noted that the issue is particularly sensitive this year since it is the 40th anniversary of the Black Power Revolution in T&T, led by Daaga and the National Joint Action Committee.

The committee said that event transformed Trinidad and Tobago society in many positive ways, including the reassertion of pride in African identity.

It noted that one expression of that pride is the wearing of dashikis and other traditional African clothing.

Letter: Kamla's victory is inevitable, but what haappens next is critical

In a democracy, the voice of the people prevails.

It took many years, but, eventually, last Janury 24th, the United National Congress (UNC) broke free of its chrysalis and became a truly democratic institution. That's why Kamla Persad-Bissessar is where she is and someone else is not any longer there.

That change was brought about because a small group realized and determined that for the UNC truly to be democratic, its actions must match its deeds.

Thus, the change was initiated by the actions of a few - principally: Austin Jack Warner, Ramesh Lawrence Maharaj and Winston "Gypsy" Peters.

And so is the case with all popular movements - a few enlightened take the first steps, then, by dint of their constant effort over time, a ripple becomes a swell, then, a wave.

But, as with all popular movements, if they are to be successful, sooner rather than later a definite personage must be identified in whom all leadership hopes are vested. The singular quality that leader must possess is charisma.

And if such a charismatic leader also possesses the required dexterity, then she would easily be able to whip the breaker into a catalytic tsunami before bringing it ashore.

That's why Kamla Persad-Bissessar is where she is and someone else is not any longer there; and why, soon enough, another person, too, no longer would be. when the last-mentioned event occurs, the whole of Trinidad and Tobago would at last be what UNC became last January 24th.

May 24th 2010, therefore, is the easy part, almost a foregone conclusion.

What happens beyond then will depend upon how entrenched the tsunamic democracy afterwards becomes.

Richard Wm. Thomas | Five Rivers, Arouca
5rivers.kid.publik@gmail.com

COP's Mayers says media report misleading

Robert Mayers says a Trinidad Guardian article Thursday suggesting that he opposes the unity deal was misleading and "deliberately calculated to...create mischief".

Read the Trinidad Guardian story: COP deputy leader hits UNC, unity deal

In a media release Thursday night the Congress of the People (COP) Deputy Leader said "the headline does not come close to reflecting the contents of the article associated with it."

The release added that Mayers "is adamant that the political arrangement which includes the Congress of the People (COP), the United National Congress (UNC), the National Joint Action Committee (NJAC), the Tobago Organisation of the People (TOP) and the Movement for Social Justice (MSJ) is the country’s best chance of removing the People’s National Movement (PNM) from government."

It added that the COP official is confident the coalition will win the general election on May 24th.

It said Mayers' insistence that COP must be the protector of the public interest is in the context of coalition partners "acting as watchdogs" over each other.

Mayers noted that COP has "consistently advocated good governance as one of its core values and his statement is in keeping with that philosophy." He added that another core principle of the COP is its members’ entitlement to express views freely.

"It is only through free expression that there can be healthy debate on important issues such as a political arrangement that includes other parties," the release stated.

It added the COP remains committed to the principle of free expression "as a cornerstone of the democratic process and, therefore, condemns in the strongest manner possible, any attempt to misrepresent healthy discussion as division within the party."

The release did not address some of the other issues raised in the article including the assertion that "If the UNC wins upcoming elections, it would therefore be nothing more than exchange." The Guardian said its story was based on a statement from the COP official.

657 students qualify as special electors for May 24 vote

The Elections and Boundaries Commission (EBC) has agreed to a request from the Trinidad and Tobago Ministry of Education to allow 657 students writing exams on election day to vote as special electors ahead of the May 24 vote.

The students are taking the CSEC and CAPE examinations.

A report from Trinidad states that the ministry had previously advised the EBC that only 25 students were qualified for the special status but it adjusted the figure to 657.

Anyone who is eligible must submit an individual application to the Returning Officer in her/his electoral district on or before Nomination Day, which is Monday.

The ministry said only those students who are registered to vote and have examinations on May 24 will be given the privilege of advance voting.

T&T to pump $315M into CAL for Air Jamaica takeover

Despite its pledge not to pump money into the Air Jamaica deal, The Trinidad and Tobago Government is now saying it will invest US$50 million (TT$315 million) in Caribbean Airlines Ltd (CAL) to meet "operating and capital expenditure" when it takes over Air Jamaica's "profitable" routes on May 1.

CAL chairman Arthur Lok Jack made the announcement Wednesday at a news conference in Port of Spain.

CAL has been discussing the business arrangement with a team from the International Monetary Fund (IMF), which is assisting with the airline's divestment.

The IMF is bothered by the huge debts of Air Jamaica and is reluctant to lend money to help in the business arrangement.

According to Lok Jack, the investment would give CAL 84 per cent ownership of the airline with the Jamaican government keeping the other 16 per cent.

Kingston is spending about US$200 million to meet Air Jamaica’s outstanding obligations during the transitional period, according to the Jamaica Information Service.

"The way we have worked it out, we expect that we would get a fairly good return on that money coming into 2011. What we expect and looking at it conservatively is US$12 million to US$15 million per year," Lok Jack told reporters.

Lok Jack said Bruce Nobles, Air Jamaica’s chief executive officer and president, would stay on until the transition is finalised. He explained that CAL will keep the 1,000 employees who stayed with Air Jamaica while the others would get separation packages funded by the Jamaican government.

Lok Jack said he expects to see growth in the airline’s performance once the transaction is completed.

He said CAL is getting an opportunity to increase revenue by almost two-thirds overnight with a fully developed business.

Lok Jack added, "So we are not taking on any costs at all and what we have happening here is that we are getting a clean operation with routes that we want, not routes that we don’t want...

“We found them (routes) to be very good routes with good load factors, they were developed routes with a number of people flying and the revenue at hand was quite substantial for those routes".

He said there are "no skeletons in the closets" and as a result CAL will now move from owning nine aircraft to approximately 15.

Works Minister Com Imbert said last month that Caribbean CAL will not be merging with or taking over debt-ridden Air Jamaica.

Imbert said Air Jamaica will be shut down and CAL will take over its profitable routes to ensure Jamaica maintains its "tourism lifeline" with its major markets in North America and Europe.

However he insisted that Government is not taking over any of Air Jamaica’s debts, which is estimated at over TT$12 billion.

Read related story: CAL to take over Air Jamaica by July 1, become Jamaica's official carrier
Related: Jamaica tourism minister has no regrets over closing Air Jamaica
Related: Guyana considering new airline to compete with Caribbean Airlines

Manning suggests UNC interfered in independence of Judiciary

Patrick Manning suggested Wednesday night that the United National Congress (UNC) might have compromised the independence of the Judiciary in Trinidad and Tobago by accepting a former judge and a magistrate.

The leader of the People's national Movement (PNM) made the charge when he addressed a political meeting in Penal.

He was responding to the news that Justice Herbert Volney had quit the High Court to run as a UNC candidate in the May 24 general election and that magistrate Ramraj Harripersad had also resigned to offer himself as a UNC candidate.

At the same time, Manning said the Judiciary is now rejoicing because Volney is no longer a judge and can be investigated.

He also asked whether both men had used their judicial positions to the advantage of the UNC.

"What decisions of these two gentlemen have been influenced by their association of the United National Congress, have they been taking decisions against the Government?" he asked

Manning added, "To what extent have they been taking decisions on the bench that are in favour of the friends and the supporters and the financiers and the well wishers of the United National Congress...to what extent has the Judiciary of Trinidad and Tobago been interfered with?"

He said the move by the two is "entirely out of order".

The PNM leader added, "What is worse they appear with their sanctimonious platitudes, the UNC, accusing the PNM and the Prime Minister in particular of all kinds of things when the ones who are really guilty of nefarious acts are the leadership and membership of the United National Congress.

"I am asking the question, has judicial independence been compromised?

He suggested that there was some sort of sinister arrangement between the two and the UNC.

"Do you believe, my dear friends, that both honourable gentlemen resigned and then decided to become candidates or do you believe that a discussion was taking place between the two honourable gentlemen and the United National Congress while they were still on the bench," he said.

Manning added, "I ask you another question, my dear friends, how long have those discussions been going on? How long has there been an association with the two members of the bench and the United National Congress?

"Has there been interference in the Judiciary by the United National Congress in violation of the concept of separation of powers?" Manning asked.

"It is not simple at all, it is fundamental and when you start to interfere with judicial independence you are interfering with the governing system at the very root at its very core and those who do that like to accuse others of being dictator.

"They accuse me of being a dictator, have I ever done anything like that my dear friends? Never!" Manning declared.

Related story: CJ concerned about independence of the Judiciary in T&T
Related story: Panday says it is time for a revolt in T&T"
Related editorial: Editorial: Time to defend our freedom

The stakes are indeed very high, the financial position of the country is very strong notwithstanding what my honourable lady friend has said...and the real prize is the Treasury of the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago, they want to put their hands on that!" he charged.

Kamla pledges tough crime policy, term limits and fixed election dates

Kamla Persad-Bissessar spoke on Wednesday night about the commitment made by Justice Volney who quit his post as a high court judge to run as a candidate for the UNC in St Joseph.

She said Volney's selfless act demonstrates the level of total commitment from the whole country. Everyone, she said, is coming together to rescue the country.

Read the story: Judge quits to run as UNC candidate

The UNC leader promised again that under her leadership there will a two-term limit for prime ministers and added that there will also be fixed dates for national elections. "But most important of all, there will be no more Patrick Manning after May 24. Vote him out," she said.

She reminded her audience that "democracy is about you and each of us...democracy is about freedom...so on May 24 go to the polls and vote them out and together, we will rise. Let us rise together and make May 24 freedom day, liberation day in Trinidad and Tobago."

Persad-Bissessar described San Juan as place that represents the nature of Trinidad and Tobago society and lamented the presence of crime in the community that has brought an unwelcome aspect of life in San Juan.

She blamed the Manning government for lacking the will to deal with crime. "Look at where they have brought us. Look at what is happening to our communities...

"Manning and Joseph are an absolute waste of time...they have failed to do the job for which you elected them," she said.

Persad-Bissessar said the whole Manning regime must go. "Tonight we say Manning not going back...the people say so...Manning going out!...Patrick have to go."

She also had a message to non-supporters. "To PNM people I say to you let us unite to get rid of Manning." She promised that no one has anything to fear under her leadership.

"You have nothing to lose...you have everything to gain. So tonight I call upon you. Let us take back our country...let us make political and economic progress," she said.

She took issue with Manning for his criticism of her leadership and said he should not worry about her but about his own leadership. "Everybody in Trinidad say Patrick have to go." She said under the People's Partnership there is no safe seat for the PNM in Trinidad and Tobago.

The UNC leader also demanded that Manning leave the media alone. "Let them do their jobs!" she demanded. "What good things can anybody say about Patrick. Does he want the reporters to lie?"

She warned all government employees that if they use state funds for campaiging they will face the consequences when a new government takes office.

She said now is the time for citizens to stand up for the country and leave Manning behind. The UNC leader said crime is the country's number one problem in the country and peldged to deal decisively with criminals.

She said she will not fraternize with criminals posing as community leaders and also promised a DNA bank to deal with crime. In additrion she promised that any police officer who is corrupt would be promptly weeded out.

The current situation speaks to moral decay by a leadership that considers the loss of life mere collateral damage, she said and pledged a multi-pronged attack to reinstate safety and security. It would include an attack on white collar crime as a priority.

Persad-Bissessar also promised to harness modern technology to help police fight crime. She said she will also put a stop to the practice of spying on private citizens.

She made it a point to promise to get police on the streets and to introduce a community court to deal with crime. The UNC leader also said she would re-egineer the justice system to make it more effective. This will include protection for witnesses and jurors.

Persad-Bissessar also said she would deal with rehabilitation to end the "revolving door" syndrome where people who commit crimes end up returning to crime as soon as they are released from jail.

She concluded by dealing with Manning's statement that he has nothing to gain by debating with her. She said that is the real problem because all he thinks of is what he can gain, instead of thinking of what the people can gain.

She said she is ready anytime, any place to debate Manning. "If you fraid to come, ah taking on anyone you send to that debate!" She suggested that he could send Calder Hart to explain what happened at UDeCOTT.

"It is not about you, it is about the people...people first, second, third...Mr Manning is concerned about what is best for him, not what is best for the people."

Persad-Bissessar also said Manning cannot debate her because he cannot discuss his record or outline any program for the nation.

She invited everyone "to hold my hand and let us walk hand in hand...to rescue this nation. Let me tell you tonight the only weak leader in this country is a man, not a woman."

She told manning he has "failed the future generations of this beloved country. Patrick leave and go... friends, take my hand...let us embark on this historic journey... we will be free again and we will rise," she said.

Top COP investigating Calder Hart transferred

The top police officer investigating former UDeCOTT executive chairman Calder Hart has been relieves of his responsibilities and transferred from the Anti-Corruption Investigation Bureau (ACIB).

The transfer of Senior Superintendent Terry Young to head the Guard and Emergency Branch (GEB) is with immediate effect.

Snr Supt Harold Phillip, former head of the Fraud Squad, has replaced Young as the UDeCOTT probe.

Acting Deputy Police Commissioner Gilbert Reyes confirmed the move in an interview with the Trinidad Express. He said acting Commissioner James Philbert made the administrative change before leaving on an overseas assignment.

Reyes told the paper the change will not affect the investigation, noting that Young's successor "is quite capable, just as Mr Young was, and we are confident that he is able to deal with the task at hand."

He added, "The investigations are ongoing and we are hoping to conclude it within the shortest possible time."

You and a team of detectives interviewed Hart at his Cascade home on April 13, three days after he returned to the country.

ACIB detectives, led by Young, had also raided the offices of UDeCOTT, Sunway (Caribbean) Construction, formerly CH Development Ltd, and chartered accountant David Montgomery and seized boxes of legal, financial and contractual documents and computer hard drives, the Express reported.

Hart is under investigation for alleged family links in the award of an $820 million contract to CH Development to construct and outfit the Ministry of Legal Affairs Tower in Port of Spain.

Attorney General John Jeremie launched the investigation in September last year after UDeCOTT tried to block the John Uff commission of enquiry.

That investigation is trying to determine if there was bid-rigging and manipulation of contracts in the award of contracts in the Ministry of Legal Affairs Tower and the Brian Lara Cricket Academy in Tarouba.

Letter: Volney matter a non-issue

Really, Mr. Manning, like a drowning man, is clutching at straws in this pre-election period.

The absurdity of suggesting that the independence of the judiciary has been compromised because of Justice Volney's announcement that he is quitting office to stand for the Alliance!

It is obvious that Justice Volney is an intelligent human being who has made a decision to do what is right for his country and will have no part of compromise.

Does Mr. Manning remember the hounding of CJ Sat Sharma by his administration?

That was the first step in demonstrating that the integrity of the Manning administration was somehow lacking. It exhibited a level of vindictiveness and megolomania that is, to put it mildly, quite frightening.

I imagine that the entire legal fraternity, along with right thinking citizens, took note of that episode - with the exception perhaps of his one or two favoured. No names called, but they hold office.

Further, was not the judiciary "compromised" when a certain Chief Magistrate refused to answer questions in a court of law? Why did our PM not have anything to say about that?

As for Mr. Manning's suggestion that he (Justice Volney) obviously held conversations with the opposition before making his decision.

Pray tell what was it in our PM's conversation with Mr. Calder Hart, the content of which is still close to his heart, that made the latter decide to throw in a honey coated sponge post haste? Nothing wrong there of course in the eyes of our PM!

He should by now know, that vote of "no confidence" or not, virtually the entire nation is now aware that there is something rotten in the state of Denmark, as the saying goes.

Mr. Manning's tall buildings are obviously obscuring his vision. Perhaps he needs an eye check to ensure that he is indeed seeing things correctly.

The entire nation is fed up with the escalating murder toll and the amount of money being thrown away whilst citizens struggle to survive, avoid flooding (when they are not begging and scraping for water!) and becoming "collateral damage".

Not everyone in CEPEP and URP are potential criminials though, so he had better not bank on their votes to get him back into office.

Further, Mrs. Persad Bissessar has let it be known that she will not be aborting that programme. She will, no doubt, ensure that it is properly run and that those involved in it do finally receive the training that Mr. Manning promised them, but so far, like a lot of his other promises, has not been able to implement.

Too busy building skyscrapers, hosting Summits, defending the likes of Calder Hart and a Finance Minister (a lawyer too!) who, fortuitously on the eve of the Clico crash, which I believe she herself announced to the nation , did not know that she was breaking a fixed deposit which she had "rolled over" on maturity (read renewed for a specific term) mere months before when she encashed same (in the nick of time?) - and expelling "wajangs".

As luck would have it, were it not for that "wajang" we would never had had the Uff CoE.

To top it off, as the findings of the latter hit the headlines the nation got wind of the Guanapo church under construction!

Now today we find hear that Snr. Supt. Terry Young - the, officer chosen to lead the investigations into the UDeCOTT and its former executive chairman, Calder Hart, and who I believe was involved in the search of the latter's premises, and questioning (if any) on his recent flying visit to T&T - has been transferred, with immediate effect, from the Anti-Corruption Investigation Bureau and reassigned as head of the Guard and Emergency Branch (GEB).

Hopefully his findings will be passed on to his successor.

Patrick Manning brought this impasse on himself and will get what he deserves come election day.

As the saying goes, "the Lord weareth pyjamas but sleepeth not" Mr. Manning.

Virginia Verity - via e/mail

CJ says Judge must not "entertain" private discussion with political party

Chief Justice Ivor Arc hie has stated that "It would be wholly improper for a sitting judge to even entertain any private discussion with any political party or group, either generally or in preparation for a transition to representative politics."

In a statement to the media, Archie added, "It is vital that judicial officers, in reality and in the perception of the public, remain independent of political parties and the cut and thrust of national politics.

"To do otherwise would compromise the independence of the judiciary and the perception of impartiality that must be preserved if the public is to have trust and confidence in the administration of justice."

The Chief Justice made the comments in confirming that Justice Herbert Volney had resigned. Volney quit earlier this week to run as a candidate for the United National Congress (UNC) in the May 26 general election. UNC leader Kamla Persad-Bissessar confirmed that Wednesday at a political meeting in San Juan.

Archie added, "While judges are expected to be independent and may make constructive comments from the bench in an effort to enhance the administration of justice, their remarks must remain within the boundaries of neutrality and decorum.

"It would be very unfortunate indeed if any judge’s remarks could be reasonably construed, not only as a crossing of those boundaries, but, with the benefit of hindsight, as the abuse of a privileged platform for a collateral objective."

Law Association president Martin Daly told the Trinidad Express that he is "absolutely shocked and distressed" over the news about Volney.

This is not the first time a judge has been involved in seeking political office.

Justice Anthony Lucky accepted a nomination from the PNM to contest the position of President. His daughter, Gillian Lucky, was appointed a temporary although she had been an MP up to 2007 and ran unsuccessfully as a COP candidate in the 2007 general election.

And Aeneas Wills, who fought Patrick Manning for the post of political leader of the People's National Movement, was subsequently made a judge.

Read the full text of the CJ's statement

Memorable quote: Chief Justice Archie on judicial independence

Read related stories:
Justice ministry is threat to Judiciary: Prof. Ryan
CJ concerned about independence of the Judiciary in T&T

Jack delcares Manning's ship is sinking

Jack Warner began his speech in Barataria Wednesday night by advising his audience that the PNM ship is sinking fast under the leadership of a clueless leader.

"I hope he could hear me. Patrick the ship is sinking, mayday, mayday! Patrick the seas are rough!" he declared and invited Gyspy to join him on stage.

The Mayaro MP obliged despite his failing voice and sanf a few lines from the famous "Sinking Ship" composed before the 1986 general election.

"In four weeks time we will have captain Kamla ... in command of the ship of state" he said.

The UNC chairman recognized the presence of members of the Congress of the People (COP) and declared that never again will a divided opposition allow the PNM to run away with the seat with a minority of seats.

He praised the Mohammed family for its contribution to public and community service. and he paid special tribute to "that patriarch" Kamal Mohammed. And he offered Kamal the best birthday gift ever by removing the PNM government.

He also praised the Muslim community for its contribution to nation building, among them former Speaker Nizam Mohammed.

Turning his guns on Patrick Manning, he said the prime minister tossed out competent members in favour of young and incompetent. He said it is a shame that the country's olderest political cannot even find candidates to fight the May 24 election.

He also spoke about the embarrassment for Keith Rowley who has been muzzled by the PNM. The party has canceled Rowley's constituency meeting scheduled for Thursday, saying Rowley is still a "prospective candidate" and is not authorized to hold the meeting.

"Rowley knows one day for thief and another day for watchman...He will strike back... and remind Manning that Calder Hart caused his downfall," he said.

He again called Manning a liar and predicted that Manning's political demise will come on May 24. He compared him to the Spanish dictator, General Franco, who never understood even in his deathbed that the people had rejected him.

"Tonight I ask you...never to forget Patrick's corruption...never forget the $1B Taruba stadium...never forget the better quality of life he promised you...which life he only gave himself."

Warner invited everyone to join the People's partnership in a rally on Sunday at which all 41 opposition candidates will be presented.

"Keep the faith. Better days are coming. Those days are coming under Kamla Persad-Bissessar and her team," he said.

COP Deputy leader slams unity deal, says it puts UNC in control

A deputy leader of the Congress of the People (COP) is not pleased with the unity accord for the May 24 general election.

And Robert Mayers says he won't be speaking on any joint platform because in his view there is no real change.

In a media statement Mayers said there is still the stigma of corruption attached to the UNC and he is disappointed that in the unity accord there is no arrangement to allow his party to act as "protector of the people and the national purse".

Mayers was out of the country when the deal was announced but acknowledged that he was never in the dark during the negotiations. He supports the idea of unity and has pledged to assist "some party candidates".

Mayers said it is the view of many COP supporters that the unity arrangement is just about getting rid of Manning.

That's a point that has been refuted by all members of the team, including COP leader Winston Dookeran who has said repeatedly that the unity pact is "unbreakable".

Mayers believes the election is really between the PNM and the UNC "with a few candidates from COP and other parties being thrown in as backdrop" to suggest that there is unity.

Column: It's worth it to dream of a united T&T

Divisive, tribal politics has been a feature of Trinidad and Tobago for so long that some people think there can be other way. But there is a way because we are one nation, one people.

Our origins, our religious beliefs, our customs, history and cultural traditions make us a nation that defines cultural relativity in which we take the best of what each of us has to offer to create a unique national mosaic. That is the true Trinidad and Tobago. Look at us at Carnival! One people! That's us.

Stephen Cadiz spoke of it on Monday night in Felicity when he appeared on a platform of the United National Congress (UNC). He told supporters when the various parties met to discuss unity the most important issue was the future of the nation.

He said that is a concept Patrick Manning and the People's National Movement (PNM) don't understand. And he urged everyone to stand up for Trinidad and Tobago. "We have to put aside our differences and start the business of building a nation," he said.

"We put our country first and on May 25 we wake up to a brand new day," he proclaimed. "We will rise, Trinidad and Tobago!"

But that's not what you will hear from some fanatics who are still dedicated to the idea that politics is about "we and dem". These are the people who still cling to the position that has got us into the mess that we are in today.

It's difficult from Toronto to gauge the true situation on the ground but from emails I have received and contacts with friends, family and colleagues I know that many UNC supporters are upset that Kamla Persad-Bissessar has "given away" too much.

For them, "strangers" in the UNC will create problems. The strangers are people like Makandaal Daaga, Errol Mc Leod and even Jack Warner. It's nothing but blatant racism.

What these people are saying is "How dare these Black people take over our Indian party!"

And there are others who have not yet forgiven Winston Dookeran and see COP as trying to force itself on the UNC, uttering the words of the party's ex-leader, Basdeo Panday.

It's not pretty and reeks of the ugly political tribalism that has disfigured Trinidad and Tobago and will continue to retard progress unless we as a people understand that there cannot and must never again be a "we and dem".

We came close in 1986 but the dream didn't last. Today, a new spirit of nationalism has taken birth with Kamla as the torchbearer.

It took a tremendous amount of struggle and swimming against the tide from men like Jack Warner to break the tradition and demonstrate that regardless of our ethnic and religious identities, service to people, the community and the nation comes first.

Kamla fought Panday and won on the premise that her leader had lost touch with the people and reneged on the solemn pledge to put people first.

Jack demonstrated that a Black man could be just as welcome in a predominantly Indian community as an Indian. For most of the people in Chaguanas West, he is just Jack, the best MP they have known.

It will take time for us to reach this level of political maturity. There are still those who are telling me that they prefer to vote for a PNM candidate than to support Jack, whom they describe as a man who has tried to steal "their party".

Others prefer to stay at home rather than cast a vote for a party led by a woman who dared to fight Panday and then "cuddle" with the likes of Jack, Dookeran, Daaga and others who are not "UNC people". You would not believe some of the trash coming from these people.

For those who came in late or who have forgotten, when the UNC took birth on a rainy day nearly 22 years ago, thousands stood in the mud in Aranguez to hear the founding leader call for race and class to be banished. (The party was formally launched on April 30, 1989 at the National Stadium)

Panday invited the masses to join his crusade for justice, freedom and equality and predicted - as Martin Luther King jr did - that people would join the movement "not because of the colour of their skins but because of the content of their minds."

Anyone who objects to the unity partnership that Kamla, Jack and others have put together to fight for the future of Trinidad and Tobago needs to revisit the history of the UNC.

And if they profess to be supporters of Panday by rejecting this alliance, they do Panday a disservice by suggesting that there is something wrong. Daaga fought for the same principles in the 1970 that Panday and the UNC later adopted.

Mc Leod fought with Panday in Oropouche in 1976 as a founding member of the United Labour Front (UFL) and went to Parliament on Panday's labour platform.

The grand coalition that Kamla and Jack put together is the culmination of Panday's dream of a truly united party based on a love for our nation, freedom, justice and equality. They have done what Panday strived to achieve for 22 years.

And anyone who supports Panday's ideals should welcome their efforts.

For a small minority on both sides of the political divide - including Manning - a national coalition bringing everybody together is a great loss because it marks the beginning of the end of political tribalism in which cronyism, nepotism, corruption and patronage take precedence over the rights of the people.

Trinidad and Tobago is in the midst of a great revolution. The test is whether this People's Partnership will prevail and if it wins, whether it will do what it proclaims.

If it does, then I can say with joy in my heart, "My country has agreed to grow up!"

Jai Parasram | Toronto 28 April 2010

UNC moves to San Juan

PNM heads to Penal

Manning won't debate Kamla, says he has nothing to gain

Patrick Manning is not interested in a debate debate with Kamla Persad-Bissessar.

The leader of the People's National Movement told reporters he has nothing to gain from such an encounter. Manning made the comment while touring his San Fernando East constituency.

The Trinidad and Tobago Chamber of Industry and Commerce has launch a Debates Commission and invited Manning and the leader of the United National Congress (UNC) to debate critical national issues on May 18, six days ahead of then election.

In backing away from the debate Manning said his preference is to walk among the people to spread his message.

"You all need to check and see what the implications of these debates are. Our political judgment is that we may do it, but not now," he told reporters. "The PNM, instead of doing these debates, prefers to do as we are doing and walk around as we are walking around now."

Manning explained that his reluctance to debate Persad-Bissessar has "nothing to do with the answers you give or any such thing." He added, "What do I have to gain by doing a debate with Mrs Persad-Bissessar? Nothing to gain by that."

Persad-Bissessar is a strong debater and would likely gain more from a debate with manning. In the January 24 internal election for her party's leadership she agreed to a three-way debate with her opponents Basdeo Panday and Ramesh L. Maharaj but both of them backed away.

People's Partnership will triumph: Kamla

Kamla Persad-Bissessar admitted to reporters Tuesday that there is some dissatisfaction among supporters of her United National Congress (UNC) over the UNC executive's decision to give up 18 seats to the People's coalition.

But she said it is for the greater national good.

"I am sure there are concerns generally, but at the end of the day the People’s Partnership shall prevail," she said.

She added, "People want the hope, they want the unity and they want the coming together of our people...There are many who will feel personal hurt at first, but I know that the greatest good will prevail."

The partnership comprises the UNC, the Congress of the People (COP), the National Joint Action Committee (NJAC), the Tobago Organization of the People (TOP) and the Movement for Social Justice (MSJ).

The UNC executive decided that it will contest 23 of the 41 seats, leaving the other 18 for its coalition partners. The UNC will not be contesting some of its 'safe' seats, including St Augustine and Pointe a Pierre.

Errol Mc Leod of the MSJ will be the Point-a-Pierre candidate and COP's Prakash Ramadhar will contest the St Augustine seat, which was held by the UNC's Vasant Bharath in the previous parliament.

The UNC has not yet completed its screening process for all the constituencies it will be fighting. So far it has only announced candidates for a few seats:

1. Siparia - Kamla Persad-Bissessar
2. Chaguanas West - Jack Warner
3. Fyzabad - Chandresh Sharma
4. Cumuto/Manzanilla - Colin Partap
5. Oropouche East - Roodal Moonilal
6. Mayaro - Winston 'Gypsy' Peters
7. Moruga/Tableland - Clifton De Couteau
8. Barataria/San Juan - Dr Fuad Khan

One of the contentious seats to be decided is Tabaquite, which was held by Ramesh L. Maharaj in the last Parliament. Challengers for Tabaquite include Anand Ramlogan, who ran as a COP candidate in 2007 and came second to Maharaj. The former attorney general is insisting that he get the nomination.

Couva North is a toss up between UNC Deputy Leader Dr Suruj Rambachan and former journalist and political activist Sunil Ramjitsingh. Rambachan is reported to be the favoured candidate for the seat that was held by former UNC leader Basdeo Panday since 1976.

Panday has not submitted his name for nomination. He objected to having to sit before a screening committee that includes UNC Chairman Jack Warner. Instead he has said he will run as an independent against Warner in Chaguanas West.

Oropouche West held by Panday's daughter is another contentious seat. Mickela Panday has been screened and says she will abide by the committee's decision and work to help her party win the election.

Couva South has several challengers to Kelvin Ramnath, one of the UNC's founding members, who like Panday, has refused to accept the leadership of Persad-Bissessar. Among candidates seeking to run there are attorney Dave Persad, sugar union boss Rudy Indarsingh and UNC Deputy Leader Lyndira Oudit.

Reports say YEStt leader Stephen Cadiz is interested in running either in Caroni Central, which Panday loyalist Hamza Rafeeq won in 2007, or Oropouche West. In Caroni East, UNC general secretary Dr Glen Ramadharsingh is trying to unseat Dr Tim Gopeesingh.

Chaguanas East, which could have been a UNC seat in 2007 in a one on one race could go to a former PNM candidate for Chaguanas, Ian Alleyne. The popular television host ran against the UNC's Manohar Ramsaran in 2002 and won just over 4,000 votes in Chaguanas.

The UNC expects to complete its screening process by Friday and plans to announce its full slate of 23 at a rally on Sunday on the eve of nomination day.

The PNM is still trying to finalize its lineup of 41. Three of its prospective candidates have had to drop out. Two of them were disqualified because they hold dual citizenship.

All hands on deck: Bharath supports Prakash for St Augustine

Vasant Bharath says he is a team player and will support Prakash Ramadhar as the candidate for the opposition in St. Augustine for the May 24 general election.

The UNC gave the seat, which Bharath won in 2007, to the Congress of the People (COP) as part of a seat sharing deal which will see the UNC contesting only 23 of the 41 seats.

St Augustine has always been one of the safest opposition seats in the country and was won by the PNM only once - in the 1971 no-vote campaign.

Bharath defeated COP leader Winston Dookeran in St Augustine in 2007.He offered himself for re-election but that became a non-issue when the UNC decided to let COP have the seat instead.

On Tuesday night Bharath urged all UNC, COP and other opposition supporters to unite and get Ramadhar elected.

"We know that the PNM will only succeed when the opposition parties are divided. And tonight I want to send a message to Patrick Manning and the Government that we are united,” Bharath said as he addressed supporters at a COP meeting.

“We have to show in St Augustine it is possible to bring former adversaries together to bring a change in the way of life. We all have differences but we have a common task at hand, building a better nation for all and I am ready and willing to help build a better society,” Bharath said.

Ramadhar said he was "humbled" to speak on a platform with patriots “like Vasant”. He turned around Manning's platform rhetoric of beating the opposition, choosing the more positive term, representation.

Ramadhar said a government under Kamla Persad-Bissesar would, “represent you in the west, represent you in the east, represent you in the north, represent you in the south and represent you in Tobago.”

COP leader Winston Dookeran - who is contesting the Tunapuna seat - said people must put things in place to bring in a new and united government to replace the collapsed Manning regime.

"We must have a principled approach to a united government. I want to prove that no seat is safe for the PNM which is why I have taken up the challenge to contest the Tunapuna seat,” Dookeran said.

“Mr Manning within this election began to raise the issue about the weak leader. When I heard it the first time, I said I will forgive him for he knows not what he said. When I heard him say it a second time I said I must feel sorry for him for he cannot distinguish between truth and deception

“But when I heard him say it a third time, I said we must expose the strength of Manning to establish who is a weak leader in TT. We must expose the strength of Manning that has put this society at risk, put the lives of people at risk, that is the strength of Manning.

"His strength has put democracy at risk. He hounded out a Chief Justice and recently deported an American citizen, that is the strength of Mr Manning!” Dookeran declared.

Dookeran said let the people decide on who is a strong leader and who is a weak leader.

“The election period is on and every time Manning makes that statement, you will see a new Dookeran on stage because enough is enough! I cannot let him hoodwink the people!” Dookeran said.

Memorable quote: Justice Volney

Related story: Judge quits to run as UNC candidate

Judge quits to run as UNC candidate

A high court judge is joining the opposition team for the May 24 general election in Trinidad and Tobago.

Justice Herbert Volney will contest the St Joseph seat as a candidate for the United National Congress (UNC). He quit his job Tuesday to take up the political offer.

Volney is known for his harsh criticism of the Manning administration's mishandling of the justice system.

He once suggested that prisoners should go on a hunger strike to highlight the need for an overhaul of the justice system.

Read the story: Frustrated judge tells prisoners to go on strike

He has also said in the past that he could not be promoted to the Appeal Court because he did not belong to an elite club.

“You must never express an independent viewpoint even though it may be the correct one to propound...You must attend all the invitations sent to you by officialdom in order to rub shoulders or appear to do so...

“You must be from the Christian right and must be seen to be involved whether as Chancellor, pastor, singer of all the psalms in the incantations of religious fervour.”

Read the story: Judge says you have to be in elite club to move to Appeal court

The PNM's Kennedy Swaratsingh won St Joseph in 2007 in a three-way race. But in 2010 it will be a two-fight, with Swaratsingh defending the seat against the former judge.

St Joseph is considered a marginal seat and was held by the UNC before. In 2007 Swaratsingh won with 7,965. The UNC’s Dr Carson Charles got 4,945 and Gillian Lucky of the COP received 4,144 votes.

In a two-way race, Volney is starting with an advantage of 1124 votes assuming the voting list is the same as it was in 2007.

In his last day in court, Volney slammed Legal Affairs Minister Peter Taylor over his failure to ensure the proper functioning of the Legal Aid and Advisory Authority.

He also criticized Taylor for failing to take to Cabinet a new draft of the Legal Aid system for better compensation for lawyers. Taylor is not running as a candidate in 2010.

Justice Volney was born in Dominica and is a naturalised citizen of Trinidad and Tobago. That gives him the legal right to stand for election since his other citizenship was involuntary.

PNM cancels Rowley's meeting

The People's National Movement has pulled the plug on Keith Rowley's campaign launch which was scheduled to take place on Thursday.

Rowley is the "prospective candidate" for Diego Martin West and had been planning to kick off his campaign for his constituency while staying clear of the national campaign.

But the party has decided that holding such a meeting was premature.

The PNM screening committee chose Rowley as the candidate on April 14, but the nomination must be ratified by the by the party’s central executive.

PNM chairman Conrad Enill dismissed suggestions that the move is to silence Rowley, noting that Rowley will be a part of the the PNM team for the May 24 general election.

However he said the persons approved by the screening committee are still considered “prospective candidates” and are therefore not authorized to hold meetings until the party ratifies their nominations.

He said while candidates can begin field work in preparation for the election they cannot hold meetings like the one Rowley had planned.

Enill noted that PNM leader Patrick Manning will make the final recommendation to the central executive on which candidates will contest the election.

He expects that will happen in time for the party's presentation of candidates in Woodford Square on Sunday; the UNC makes its presentation at Mid Centre Mall, Chaguanas on sunday as well.

Column: Political games in the PNM

When 2010 started the last thing on Patrick Manning's mind was that within four months he would be fighting for his political life.

He had already banished Keith Rowley, had planned to push Penny Beckles aside and the prospect that Basdeo Panday would be returned as leader of the United National Congress (UNC) in the party's internal election brought comfort to his heart.

What could be better for the Prime Minister? The unexpected.

Two things happened that upset Manning's political apple cart. A revolt from within started to gain momentum and Kamla Persad-Bissessar emerged as the new leader of the UNC in a decisive landslide that pushed Panday to near political oblivion.

By February 24 when Kamla formally dethroned Panday and became the leader of the opposition as well, Manning knew he had a problem.

Kamla's 10-1 victory against Panday spawned a new spirit of nationalism unlike anything the country had seen. Even high ranking PNMites like Beckles were congratulating her; the women's constituency was fully behind her and she knew that she was standing on the threshold of Whitehall.

The opportunity came much sooner than she expected when Manning, fearing a palace coup, shut down the Parliament on April 8 and set the stage for an election two and a half years after winning a strong majority.

Scandal after scandal had weakened the governing party and the inexperience of most of his cabinet - and his own blunders - made matters worse.

What added salt to Manning's political wounds was the constant war with the likes of Rowley who refused to roll over and die; instead many within the PNM rallied behind the man who gave Manning a near fatal "Hart" attack.

Today Manning is insisting that the race is just starting and there is a long distance to travel before the final tally on May 24. He is predicting that a "weak" Kamla would buckle under pressure and a hastily assembled coalition would come apart. He is counting on winning again, despite the heavy odds in favour of the opposition.

In 2007 victory was easy.
Two strong opposition parties fighting each other provided the ideal opportunity to give him seats that he would have lost in a one and one fight.

In the end he walked away with the prize although the majority of electors rejected him. The repeat performance he was counting on failed to materialize when Panday was thrown out as leader of the UNC.

Kamla kept her campaign pledge to "heal the wounds and unite" the opposition and immediately dedicated herself to sealing a unity deal with Winston Dookeran's Congress of the People (COP) and other political groups.

To his dismay Manning found that the opposition he considered weak, unprepared anf fragmented had found a way to unite and fight him one on one.

And although there is no scientific poll yet suggesting that Manning's retirement is at hand, it is clear from what is happening on the ground that Kamla's time has come.

For Manning that is bad news. Not only does he stand to lose an election that was not due for another 30 months, he risks losing his position in the party.

Keith Rowley fought for and won his nomination as a PNM candidate not to sing Manning's praises, but to guarantee his bona fide as a PNM MP when the time comes to overthrow Manning.

He had planned to launch his campaign for Diego Martin West on Thursday, but the party has now canceled the meeting, saying it is unauthorized since Rowley's nomination has not been ratified by the party.

Rowley had planned to stay within his constituency and avoid the PNM national platform. And for good reason.

After his open war with Manning and his declaration that the Manning administration was the most corrupt ever, how can he in all honestly campaign for the Manning PNM?

And on the other side of the coin after Manning's many attempts to paint Rowley as corrupt how can he present Rowley as part of a clean, honest team?

And that is where the rules of this political game change.

Rowley is not campaigning for the PNM to win this election; Rowley is campaigning for Rowley to win a seat in the next Parliament as a man of integrity who helped bring down a corrupt Manning administration.

His next move would be to demand that the party replace Manning for having caused the collapse of a majority government in 30 months and to offer himself as an alternative - Mr Clean himself. And there are enough people in high places in the PNM who would dance according to that kind of music.

Once firmly in charge, Rowley's next act would be to launch a continuous attack on the new administration, hoping to inflict mortal wounds quickly that would lead to its demise in a single term. Then the PNM and a sanitized leadership would return to Whitehall and it would be business as usual for the party that Eric Williams founded in 1956.

But maybe not.

If Kamla and her team do what they promise and run a government that is above board, develop a meritocracy in which everyone is equal and treated fairly, maintain a partnership involving the state, labour and business, get the economy fixed and tackle crime at its source the PNM would find it hard to make another breakthrough.

But the race the to 2010 finish line hasn't even started in earnest. Anything can happen in the next few weeks.

And don't be surprised if Mr Manning is back. If that happens despite the anti-Manning political tsunami spawned by Kamla's leadership, despite the mass following for this new people's opposition, then no one should complain.

Why? Because in a democracy, the people get the government they deserve.

Jai Parasram | Toronto, 26 April 2010

Weak coalition cannot create jobs: Manning

Patrick Manning is telling supporters the coalition headed by Kamla Persad-Bissessar is so "inherently unstable" that it won't be able to create the right jobs for Trinidad and Tobago's "highly-educated workforce".

The leader of the People's National Movement (PNM) told supporters his government has invested in heavy industrialization, which he said is good for the country.

“When they come to ask for your vote, you must ask them what their industrialisation policy is...Are they going to say no more heavy industry will be allowed in Trinidad and Tobago in the future, as the NAR had said?" he asked.

He spoke of his government's policy of creating jobs in such heavy industries as an aluminium smelter, an iron and steel complex, and a plastics industry.

The Prime Minister said the country needs "strong, courageous and determined leadership" that can provide a program to carry out a clear vision for development. he said the opposition vision is shortsighted. "The only vision they have is to get rid of Manning,” he declared.

He also took issue with an opposition proposal for a higher minimum wage, suggesting that labour members of the coalition government would push the government to make it so high that it will make businesses uncompetitive, resulting in mass unemployment.

He urged citizens to keep the government they know rather than opt for one that is not known. "Don’t buy cat in bag!" he advised.

he also suggested that UNC leader Kamla Persad-Bissessar is not strong enough to lead the coalition and the Government.

Letter: Deciphering Kamla's Candidacy strategy

The louder the call of Mr. Ramesh L. Maharaj for inclusion as a lower house candidate, the more one must seek his reasoning.

Ramesh is undoubtedly a distinct asset to the Opposition forces. However, placing him in the lower house to serve under one for whom he has shown the greatest resistance spells danger in large letters.

Ramesh has never left any doubt that his ambition is to lead the UNC and his campaign for that office was unabashed. His refusal to support Kamla as Opposition leader, confirmed his distaste for her leadership.

It is a matter of history that Mr. Panday rued the day he brought Ramesh back into the fold. The strategic support of convenience which Ramesh gave to Panday as Opposition leader was designed only to keep Kamla from that position.

The painful days of Ramjack have not been forgotten and Ramesh’s demand to be in the lower house has clear implications.

Others have also expressed their leadership aspirations, Jack, Dookeran and perhaps others harbour such. But Jack and Dookeran are constrained by their self realization of Kamla’s supremacy and by circumstances they cannot breach.

Ramesh has wider appeal at the grassroots and has appealed to this openly. Jack knows his own limitations. Dookeran has had the ground eroded from under his feet by the swirling of public sentiment.

Ramesh’s appeal to grassroots sentiment will be again used to wrest plum roles and positions. Kamla will always be at bay.

It is my strong recommendation that Kamla stay firm and allow no strong contenders particularly one with a record as open as Ramesh for palace coups.

It is clear that others will face the axe so that Ramesh’ exclusion is not typified as vindictive. IMHO, it is Kamla’s duty to bite the bullet now and stand firm.

M.F. Rahman | via email

Joseph revokes order, ousted American free to return to TT

National Security Minister Martin Joseph on Monday revoked an order refusing entry to Trinidad to American political strategist Bernard Campbell.

Authorities at Piarco International Airport refused entry to Cambell last Thursday when he arrived to take up an assignment as a political adviser to the United National Congress (UNC) for the May 24 general election.

He was turned back on the grounds that he was considered to be "an undesirable inhabitant or, or visitor to Trinidad and Tobago". It's a rarely used provision.

The opposition was outraged at the government action and UNC leader Kamla Persad Bissessar accused the Manning administration of bullying a foreign national while cuddling with others like Calder Hart.

Read the story: Kamla slams Manning regime for bullying U.S. citizen

A media release from the ministry stated: "the disclosure by the Opposition Leader that Mr Campbell was here to work was at variance with his official declaration that he was here on business."

UNC Leader Kamla Persad-Bissessar told a political meeting Monday night the Government’s decision to lift the rejection order came after she threatened the ministry with legal action on behalf of Campbell, whom she described as her client.

Her letter stated: "My client has been adversely affected by your decision that there was reliable information or advice that my client was an ’undesirable’ visitor.

"Section 16 of the Judicial Review Act, 2000, obliges you to provide my client with a statement of reasons for this decision and the consequent prohibition of my client’s entry into this country.

"In the circumstances, I must call upon you to comply with your obligations under the Judicial Review Act and render a proper, adequate and intelligible statement of reasons to me within seven days of the date of this letter."

She said she received a call from the ministry advising of the change and demanded that the ministry put it in writing.

Commenting on the matter, Joseph told the media, "We will do the necessary thing as it relates to allow him to legitimately come in to do whatever function he is required to perform. We expect that will happen in short order."

He explained that "the circumstances under which Mr Campbell came into the country was not in keeping, strictly speaking, with the laws of Trinidad and Tobago."

Other political leaders, including COP's Winston Dookeran and UNC chairman Jack Warner also slammed the authorities for their high-handed action.

And the U.S. embassy in Port of Spain expressed concern, saying it would like to know on what grounds Campbell was refused entry. Public Affairs Officer Matthew Cassetta told reporters Monday the Embassy is still in discussions with the ministry and he was not at liberty to disclose the nature of those discussions.

Campbell is a high profile professional whose firm worked on the Obama campaign in the United States.

He told media in Trinidad he has no intention of returning to Trinidad while Patrick Manning is prime minister. At the same time he said he plans to return on May 25 when Persad-Bissessar is head of government.

At first the national security minister insisted that he had nothing to answer to anyone about the incident.

Read the story: T&T doesn't have to explain Campbell incident: Joseph