Tuesday, May 31, 2011

CONCACAF strikes back, wants Blazer to explain conduct

The acting President of CONCACAF on Monday ordered a halt to all contractual arrangements with the law firm, Collins and Collins with immediate effect.

That's the firm that prepared the file that was used to cause the provisional suspension of Jack Warner and three others.

Lisle Austin called on Warner's accuser, General Secretary Chuck Blazer, to provide an explanation within 48 hours on what authority he used to unilaterally hire the law firm Collins and Collins to conduct investigations into allegations of misconduct by members of CONCACAF.

The CONCACAF Senior Vice President was elevated to the position of acting president Monday morning following the controversial suspension of Warner by the FIFA Ethics Committee on Sunday afternoon.

Austin dispatched a letter dated May 30th, 2011 to Blazer's hotel hotel in Zurich, asking Blazer to provide minutes of the meeting or any evidence to show that the FIFA Executive Committee authorised the hiring of the law firm.

The Executive Committee is the duly elected body of the CONCACAF, charged solely with the responsibility of making decisions of such nature.

Austin has also called upon the General Secretary to explain the procedure and rationale behind his decision on Monday to select five non-elected members of CONCACAF to represent the Confederation at Tuesday's congress.

Warner: Blatter has to be stopped

Better times - Jack and Blatter pose for reporters
The drama unfolding at FIFA headquarters in Switzerland is getting more intriguing as Jack Warner prepares to challenge the legality of his provisional suspension from the world football governing body.

On Sunday, the Ethics Committee suspended Warner and Asian Confederation President Mohamed Bin Hammam pending the outcome of a full inquiry into allegations they bribed officials.

Warner expressed shock Sunday when he learned about the decision, which he said had not been communicated to him. He charged that he did not get a fair hearing and that the Ethics Committee had made its decision before considering all the evidence.

"I must say that I look on the suspension as the worst form of justice by any sporting organisation. They came there pre-meditated, whatever you said they were not prepared to listen." Warner said Monday.

"They (the committee) were hand-picked to do a task and they did just that. I said before, FIFA will feel a tsunami coming. Trust me, you have not seen it yet. At the end of the day, Blatter has to be stopped."


Blatter is seeking re-election as FIFA's president for another four years and with no challenger on the slate now it looks like he will get the job without a fight when the election is held Wednesday.

Warner has claimed that Blatter attempted to buy votes off his Caribbean Football Federation (CFU) members and added that Secretary General, Jerome Valke, told him that Qatar had bought the 2022 World Cup.

Warner also told reporters that he told Valcke that "at the CFU meeting held in Trinidad on May 10th...FIFA through Mr Blatter organised gifts of laptops and projectors to all members of the Caribbean and no objections have been made today of this to date".

Valcke has confirmed that an email he sent suggesting the 2022 World Cup was 'bought' was genuine, but he said Monday he meant that Qatar used its financial strength to legitimately lobby for votes.

Blatter held a news conference to deal with the issues but avoided many pertinent questions. However he made the point that the matter has caused great damage to FIFA's image. He insisted that there is no crisis in football and that "some difficulties" will be resolved from within.

He refused to react to Warner's suggested that "Blatter must be stopped".


He was evasive on many points during the half hour media conference and at one point said, “I will not answer this question...I am the president of FIFA, you cannot question me.”

Jack says report that exonerated him offers hope for truth and transparency

Jack Warner said Monday he has regained some hope in the power of truth and transparency.

The FIFA Vice President made the statement in a media release in reaction to the report of the independent investigator on the bribery allegations made by the former England FA chairman, Lord Treisman.

The report cleared Warner and three other top FIFA executive members of any wrongdoing.

Warner said this is proof that "Whenever the truth is told, people will always be able to have their names exonerated."

He added, "The report confirms what I have been saying ever since these fallacious and malicious allegations were made.

"It is an irrefutable fact that had confidentiality agreements not debar certain people from revealing their full knowledge of all matters surrounding many who are the source of the allegations against me, I would be able to more freely fight the conspiracy being waged against me."

Warner said Lord Treisman, like those "who continue to malign my name with these allegations of bribery, will see their efforts come to futility because I remain resolute in the truth that I have done nothing wrong."

He also mentioned the FIFA Ethic Committee that handed him a provision suspension Sunday, saying "It should be instructive to the FIFA Ethics Committee as to just how independent enquiries should be conducted."

He said the abuse of power that the committee exhibited in its hearing "is a far cry from what such a body should be exhibiting."

The Trinidad and Tobago Works and Transport minister said, "It must have pained Mr. Blatter and Mr. Valcke to read this report. But the fact which cannot be changed is as Valcke declared "all four are completely clean." It is because of this complete cleanness why Sir Dave Richards, who is no friend of mine, can say truthfully that he has never heard me ask for money or ask for funds to be channelled through me."

UNC supports Jack

The United National Congress (UNC) issued a media statement Monday in support of its chairman, Jack Warner, who has been temporarily suspended from his position as FIFA VIce President and is facing a full investigation over allegations of corruption.

Warner has said the process was flawed and is challenging its legality.

The statement from deputy chairman Dr Fuad Khan urged members to resist "rumour-mongering, hearsay and any vilification that may lead to Warner's conviction as FIFA vice-president." And he called on party members to stand behind Warner.

"Warner is our chairman, and by the rights of any fair and just legal system, he must be presumed innocent until otherwise proven," Khan said.

Khan said those who oppose the party are seeking to use what happened over the weekend to try to strike out at the UNC. He reminded members that Warner has made significant contributions to this country and to the sporting arena.

"This entire affair has saddened us all, but like family, we will rally to the defence of one of our own. Consequently, until the outcome of the FIFA enquiry, there is no justifiable reason for Warner to demit office as Minister of Works and Transport within the Government of the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago.

"To do this would, in effect, send the signal that we are convicting Warner without evidence and on a matter that is not related to Government business," he said.

Warner is also getting support from individual UNC constituencies.

However the chairman of the Congress of the People (COP) thinks Warner should step aside from his ministerial duties until the investigation is completed.

In a media release, Joseph Toney said, "A critical aspect of good governance is the maintenance of standards of ethics and integrity."

The opposition People's National Movement (PNM) is also calling on the Prime Minister to remove Warner, saying she should act the same way she did with Mary King.

The Prime Minister has already stated her support for her minister. And commentators have noted that there is no comparison between the matter regarding Warner and that of King, who was fired after she failed to disclose her connection with a family business that won a contract from her ministry.

PM celebrates Indian Arrival Day, pays tribute to pioneers who helped build T&T


Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar was busy over the long holiday weekend, joining citizens and various groups across the country to celebrate the 166th anniversary of Indians in Trinidad.

She urged everyone to remember the sacrifices of the pioneers who came here for a better life and to acknowledge their contribution to helping to build Trinidad and Tobago as a free and democratic society.


 "It is a day when liberty and laughter go hand-in-hand - when we can acknowledge that while we have problems to deal with, we are happy and proud because our forefathers not only dealt with more serious problems, but left us a blueprint as to how we should deal with our challenges as a nation and a people," she said at an event at St. Augustine, where she was presented with the SWAHA organisation's SWADESHI award for being the first woman to be Prime Minister of Trinidad and Tobago.

She dedicated the award to those who came before her.

"I am getting this award tonight for being the first woman who became Prime Minister of this land, but I must say that it is truly not mine alone.

"I’ve been blessed to have had mentors and role models in my life, many of who were the women unsung heroes of the Indentureship and Slavery system whose lives were lessons of determination, courage, dedication, hope and unfaltering faith.

"They taught me by example that a life enriched by service to others is a rich life indeed.

"It is therefore fitting that I dedicate this award tonight to the thousands of women from the Indentureship period who toiled the fields, and dedicated themselves to their families to ensure that we, their children of today, had the chance to educate ourselves and escape that destiny of poverty.

"To them and to you I say thank you and may we always continue to emulate their greatness of spirit and resolve, dedication and love for our children, our fellow citizens and our country. 

PM Kamla performs aarti for one of her community's elders
Persad-Bissessar also spoke of the the difficulty that Indians faced.

"They toiled in the cane fields and fought in spirit against the Colonial systems of oppression and discrimination, they pledged their lives and their newly found determination and sacred honor to found the principles of this nation as we know it today.

"Their legacy to us today is reflected in the schools that we learnt from, our advanced educational systems, our developed business sector, our economic stability, our strong family and religious values, our deep sense of unity and pride in our country and our commitment to tolerance and harmony as a diversified people."

In a speech on Sunday, she reminded the nation of the value Indians placed on educating their children and said that is why her government is devoted so many resources to education from the earliest stages of a child's life to tertiary education and beyond.

She said all parents must embrace the educational opportunities now available. Education, she said, is not book knowledge and academic pursuits but also the everyday occupations that require other skills.
MP Stacy Roopnarine rides a float during Indian Arrival Day celebrations



Tax amnesty ends; many delinquent accounts remain

A tax amnesty for citizens declared last September by Finance Minister Winston Dookeran ends Tuesday.

It applies to returns, penalties and interest on outstanding taxes for the years of income up to 2009.

Starting Wednesday, June 12, the Board of Inland Revenue (BIR) plans to begin to a strict enforcement policy to collect billions of dollars in outstanding taxes. It is likely to use garnishee orders and other actions, including levying on the assets of taxpayers with delinquent accounts.

When the amnesty was announced, officials said taxpayers were owing about $13 billion - more than the national budget.

The finance minister decided to waive all interest charges and other penalties to encourage everyone to pay up all outstanding taxes and declared the amnest to the end of May 2011.

Manning ends walk Tuesday with march into San Fernando

Patrick Manning will complete his "democracy march" Tuesday with a "triumphal" entry into Harris Promenade, San Fernando where he plans to hold a public meeting.

The former prime minister began his protest against his suspension from Parliament last week Wednesday from the Red House and has passed through several communities along the way.

On Monday he reached Taruba, in the shadow of one of the monuments of his years as head of government - the unfinished billion-dollar Brian Lara stadium.

All along he has had the support of some loyalists, including his spouse, former cabinet minister Hazel Manning, his sons, and a former foreign minister, Ralph Maraj.

However the central executive of his party has refused to support him and join the former PNM leader. Manning has complained that PNMM leader Keith Rowley did not take his phone calls when he tried several times to advise him of the protest event.

Only one elected PNM MP - Alicia Hospedales - joined Manning for part of the walk.

Speaking with reporters Monday Manning said there will be an different approach to the end of the long walk. “We will be doing a march instead of a walk,” he said.

He plans to leave the Taruba site at 5pm for San Fernando, hoping to cover the 3.2 miles in time for his meeting in Harris Promenade. 

Maraj addressed supporters Monday stating that Manning has demonstrated  stamina, courage, and resilience. he said no one but Manning has ever done what the former PM did over the last six days.

Maraj said Manning was “demonstrating in a very symbolic way the kind of quality we have, the kind of quality we need in our leaders.”

Monday, May 30, 2011

Happy Indian Arrival Day

Celebrating a lasting bond - 1845-2011

Independent probe clears Jack of allegations made by ex-England FA head

Jack Warner with Lord Triesman
The English Football Association announced on Sunday that Jack Warner and three other FIFA executives have been cleared of bribery allegations made against them by the former head of the FA, Lord Triesman.

Triesman, who ran the FA and its 2018 World Cup bid until last May, claimed that Jack Warner, Nicolas Leoz, Ricardo Teixeira and Worawi Makudi had engaged in "improper and unethical" conduct.

However an independent report commissioned by the FA exonerated the four of them. "All four are completely clean," said Fifa general secretary Jerome Valcke.

"I have just got the FA report... and I hope Fifa will agree to make it public because all the people here...are completely clean of all the allegations made by David Triesman a few weeks ago.

"I'm glad the person appointed by the FA took time to hear not only Triesman but also David Dein, Simon Johnson, Andy Anson and other people who were part of the bid."

Triesman made the accusation during a parliamentary inquiry that was trying to find out why England lost the bid to host the 2018 World Cup, which FIFA awarded to Russia. England secured only one vote other than that of is own delegate.

Triesman accused Warner, a Fifa vice-president and CONCACAF of asking for a bribe of £2.5m to build an education centre in Trinidad and for another £500,000 to buy Haiti's World Cup TV rights.

Valke said Dave Richards, the chairman of the Premier League, disputed Triesman's account. He added, "Dave Richards has not said he heard Jack Warner ask for money in his presence, or ask for funds to be channelled through him."


Warner had previously dismissed Triesman's charges as nonsense.

FIFA suspends Jack, Bin Hamman pending probe; says it's not a determination of guilt or innocence

FIFA temporarily suspended top executive committee members Mohamed Bin Hammam and Jack Warner Sunday following a meeting of its ethics committee in Zurich.

However the committee made it clear that its decision is not an indication of proof or guilt on the part of both men since the committee did not have jurisdiction to make such a determination.


The FIFA Ethics Committee is a judicial body, which is independent of the rest of the organisation. Its task is to impartially evaluate evidence and facts and make a determination on the issues placed before it.

At a news conference Sunday in Zurich, FIFA said the world governing body for football said it will now open a full investigation into allegations that financial incentives were offered to members of the Caribbean Football Union (CFU).

FIFA also suspended CFU officials Debbie Minguell and Jason Sylvester, who did not appear before the body Sunday.

However, the committee decided that it would take no action against the President of FIFA Sepp Blatter, who now stands to be re-elected unopposed since his only challenger, bin Hamman pulled out of the race Sunday morning. FIFA confirmed that the presidential election will go ahead as planned on Wednesday.

The Ethics Committee said its role in the matter was to determine whether any of the accused had breached the organisation's ethic rules. It said based on the evidence presented both in writing and orally it concluded that the four have a case to answer.

It made it clear, however, that Sunday's ruling is not an indication or whether anyone is guilty of anything. It insisted that each of the four is considered innocent. It said Warner and the others will have an opportunity to defend themselves at the inquiry and confront their accusers. FIFA said its next step is to ensure that the
 investigation is not compromised.

The Ethics probe developed over accusations made by American FIFA executive member Chuck Blazer, who compiled a file for FIFA accusing Warner and bin Hammam of offering bribes for votes at a meeting of the CFU in Trinidad on 10 and 11 May.

Blazer claimed that the football executives offered up to US$40,000 to members of the CFU at the meeting in Trinidad.

Bin Hammam countered that Blatter was aware of some wrongdoing but did not report it. He said that in itself constituted a breach of FIFA's ethics code.
Warner has always insisted that he has done nothing wrong.

PM Kamla bats for Jack: "I stand by him."

Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar issued a statement Sunday evning in support of Works and Transport Minister Jack Warner following Warner's provisional suspension from FIFA pending a formal investigation of allegations against him.

JYOTI has published the full statement below:

It is a fundamental tenet of the rule of law that a man is innocent until proven guilty.

This right is enshrined in the constitution of the republic of Trinidad and Tobago and is an important pillar in our system of justice.

And so, the decision by FIFA to initiate a “provisional suspension” of its Vice President Jack Warner, pending investigation is not a determination of guilt but part of a process that we trust will be fair and unprejudiced.

A “provisional suspension” is not to be equated with a finding of guilt, far less a sentence based on a finding of wrong doing.

The process must now be allowed to go its full course since as I said, a person is presumed innocent until proven guilty.

FIFA is an international sport body that is not part of the Government of Trinidad and Tobago; we therefore have no knowledge about its procedures and the dynamics of its unique internal politics.

It would be unfortunate if we made premature adverse judgement and pronouncement on a matter that is under investigation. This would be contrary to the spirit and letter of the laws of our land.

I am fully aware that events like this involving a Senior Cabinet Minister will be of immense concern to the people of Trinidad and Tobago


Likewise, I am concerned by the allegations made and expect an update from Mr. Warner upon his return, which he has assured he will do.

At this time, there is no reason for me to arrive at any conclusion regarding the allegations made against Mr. Warner.

A ‘son of our soil’ who served this nation faithfully at that very football organisation and who was instrumental in leading Trinidad and Tobago to its very first World Cup qualification just a few years ago must be allowed every opportunity to present his case against the allegations made about him.

Consequently, at this time I will not prejudge the allegations against Minister Warner, and until there is evidence to the contrary, I stand by him.

Jack states his position, maintains he did nothing wrong


FIFA Vice President Jack Warner released a statement Sunday afternoon on his provisional suspension from the organisation. JYOTI has printed the full statement below:

I attended the FIFA enquiry today (Sunday) at 12 noon pursuant to a request made of me by FIFA to answer allegation made by Chuck Blazer, General Secretary of CONCACAF.

I have learned this evening via the media that I have been provisionally suspended by the FIFA Ethics Committee. 


This has come both as a shock and surprise to me. At the conclusion of the enquiry I specifically requested that I be notified of any decision as I had learned via the media before attending the hearing that a decision would be handed down at 5:00PM. Despite leaving my contact details, up to this point, I still have not received any notification from the FIFA.

At the hearing I indicated that I submitted two written statements outlining my position. I expressed my disappointment with the way in which the enquiry was conducted as I was given less than twenty four hours to submit a statement for consideration by the committee and, moreover, one of the five members of the Committee is from Uruguay and did not have the value of a translated version of my or Mr bin Hammam's submission. This lack of translation services brings into question the issue of due process.

In addition, FIFA did not have the courtesy to provide me with copies of the allegations before the hearing and it was only during the hearing were the allegations read to me.

At the hearing, among other things, I was asked about the special meeting with the CFU to hear Mr Bin Hammam and whether such a meeting was normal I indicated that President Blatter earlier this year had held a similar meeting in South Africa with thirty seven countries and no objections had been made of that to date. In fact this has been the practice of FIFA in holding meetings with member countries before elections.

I denied the allegations that I made statements at the CFU meeting about gifts being given by Mr Bin Hammam. I also indicated that at the Miami CONCACAF Congress on May 3rd Mr. Blatter made a gift of one million USD to CONCACAF to spend as it deems fit. 

This annoyed President Michel Platini who was present and he approached Secretary General Jerome Valcke complaining that Mr Blatter had no permission from the Finance Committee to make this gift to which Jerome replied that he will find the money for Mr Blatter.

I also indicated at the CFU meeting held in Trinidad on May 10 which was requested by Mr. Bin Hammam, FIFA through Mr. Blatter organised gifts of laptops and projectors to all members of the Caribbean and no objections have been made today of this to date.

In my statement I attached letters from thirteen Federations whose members attended the CFU Meeting where the allegations of gifts were made.

These statements from the 13 members denied the allegations that have been made against me and any participation of these individuals in the act complained of. While with regard to the allegation of payment only one statement was submitted by Collins & Collins.

On May 18 when I realised that the political battle between Blatter and Bin Hammam was getting out of hand I wrote Secretary General Valcke telling him, among other things, that the outcome of the elections may cause some fracture in the Arab world which we can ill afford now and that I will like to ask Bin Hammam to withdraw from the race. 

To which Jerome replied to me and I quote :

"For MBH, I never understood why he was running. If really he thought he had a chance or just being an extreme way to express how much he does not like anymore JSB. Or he thought you can buy FIFA as they bought the WC. I have a bet since day one, he will withdraw but on June 1st after his 10 min speech. By doing so he can say he push Blatter to make new commitments bla bla bla and get out under applause. Before means he is a looser. So...He will get some votes. Less than 60 today after CAF support. It will be the "coup de grace" if you would officially send a message as the CONCACAF President by saying CONCACAF supports unanimously. So I am not giving you an advice but just my feeling about what I think is the situation."


Despite the plea from SG Valcke, I refused to give any advice about how CONCACAF will be voting.

At no time during this matter was I ever contacted by Mr. Blazer nor did he contact the Executive or the Emergency Committee of the CONCACAF and it is informative for one to look at Mr Blazer's credibility by referring to the report of the NY District Court Judge in the matter between Master Card and Visa in the FIFA matter of 7th December 2006 .

Prakash to announce that he will seek COP leadership

Prakash Ramadhar is expected to make it official Monday and announce that he is seeking the leadership of the Congress of the People (COP).

The St Augustine MP is holding a news conference at which party officials say he will announce that he will run for the top post.

Ramadhar had been reluctant to oppose his leader, Winston Dookeran. However Dookeran cleared the way on Saturday by announcing that he would not run again,

Ramadhar is one of the founders of COP and is a favourite to take over the leadership of the party. Both he and Dookeran are strong defenders of the People's Partnership so there will be continuity if he wins.

Ramadhar's cabinet colleague Anil Roberts is also seeking the leader's job in the COP's internal election on July 3. The election would be based on a one-member, one vote system similar to what happens in the COP's coalition partner, the United National Congress (UNC).
  
Dookeran has said he will continue to hold his cabinet position as long as the Prime Minister him to. However he is not sure about whether he will contest the next general election, which is not due for at least four years.

Dookeran's departure from COP leadership won't affect government: PM Kamla

Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar told reporters Sunday the decision by Winston Dookeran to step down as political leader of the Congress of the People (COP) will not affect the People's Partnership Government.

"I am saddened by his decision but I think he knows best as to what he can do and cannot do. He has made it clear that he is in succession planning and see leaders who will not give up at some point in time. In my view he needs to be congratulated on his very brave stand," she said.

Persad-Bissessar said Dookeran is an asset to the government, adding that she is confident that he would continue to work for the people of Trinidad and Tobago.

"He is a great asset to the partnership and I look forward to continue working with Mr Dookeran," she said.

Dookeran announced on Saturday that he is stepping down. His party will elect a new leader in its internal election on July 3. Nomination day is June 12.

MP for St Augustine Prakash Ramadhar is a popular choice to succeed Dookeran. However he has not yet announced if he will seek the COP's top job. Another COP MP, Anil Roberts, and COP Vice Chairman Vernon de Lima are the only declared candidates so far.

PM Kamla's official schedule for Indian Arrival weekend


Letter: Who's really in charge of the PNM?

Mr Keith Rowley, instead of you, Fitzgerald Hinds and Colm Imbert focusing on the Prime Minister and her Government, I think you all should pay more attention to Mr Patrick Manning and stop being so naive.

A blind man can see Manning is doing everything in his power to be the leader of the People's National Movement (PNM) again. Look at what is happening in the party; Mr Manning has his supporters and you have yours, so who really is the leader of the Opposition? Is it you, Mr Rowley, or is it Mr Manning? Is there a split?

I believe you should keep your focus on Mr Manning because his intention is to get back in the game; forget Kamla and Jack. Let Jack handle his stories, and Kamla did not break any law.

Manning is on the move to kick you out again. Everything that happened to Mr Manning, he looked for it, so I cannot understand why you all want to support him with his foolishness by staging a walk to highlight his suspension from Parliament. 


He should stay out of Parliament for good because his political life has expired. All these people who are walking with him now, I want to know where were they on election night when he needed them most; you all are so insipid.

I did not see Occah Seepaul march when Manning had her under house arrest. I did not see Morris Marshall march when he was treated like a dog nor Basdeo Panday when he was suspended for using his laptop in the house nor the policeman who Manning got fired. 

I did not see any of them march, even though Panday is now supporting Manning in his march—that I cannot understand—but everyone knows Panday is a "doctor shop knife", he cuts on both sides.

Mr Rowley, watch your back because the ex-captain is coming with full force to throw you out again.

Modicia Martin | via e-mail

Bin Hamman drops out of FIFA presidential race

Mohamed bin Hammam dropped out of the FIFA presidential race Sunday hours before arriving at FIFA headquarters in Zurich to answer charges before the world football body's Ethic Committee.

His move leaves the field clear for the incumbent Sepp Blatter to be elected unopposed for another four-year term as President of FIFA.

However he too is to face the same committee to clarify allegations of campaign bribes.

Both bin Hammam and FIFA Vice-President Jack Warner have repeatedly said there is no truth in allegations that they paid some Caribbean voters at a meeting in Port of Spain three weeks ago. 

Warner had invited bin Hammam to Trinidad to make a presentation to CONCAF, which Warner heads. The Qatari FIFA executive was denied a visa to go to the United States to make his presentation, so Warner provided the opportunity for him to do it in Port of Spain in the interest of fairness.

It was CONCACAF general secretary, American Chuck Blazer, who complained about his FIFA executive committee colleagues bin Hammam and Warner.

Bin Hammam decided to run for the presidency after helping Qatar secure hosting rights for the 2022 World Cup.

He announced his withdrawal on his personal website.

“Recent events have left me hurt and disappointed — on a professional and personal level,” bin Hammam wrote. “It saddens me that standing up for the causes that I believed in has come at a great price — the degradation of FIFA’s reputation. This is not what I had in mind for FIFA and this is unacceptable.

“I cannot allow the name that I loved to be dragged more and more in the mud because of competition between two individuals. The game itself and the people who love it around the world must come first. It is for this reason that I announce my withdrawal from the presidential election.

“I pray that my withdrawal will not be tied to the investigation held by the FIFA ethics committee as I will appear before the ethics committee to clear my name from the baseless allegations that have been made against me,” bin Hammam said.

Blazer delivered a file containing sworn statements from some Caribbean football leaders that sparked an explosive round of allegations, denials and conspiracy accusations in the final days of campaigning.

Bin Hammam and Warner, a 28-year FIFA veteran, are accused of arranging bribes for up to 25 presidential voters on a campaign visit.

Blazer claimed that Caribbean Football Union members were offered US$40,000 each at a conference in Trinidad May 9-10 conference in Trinidad, where Warner is a government minister.

Bin Hammam has acknowledged paying travel and accommodation expenses, and conference costs, but has denied vote-buying.

Instead, he implicated Blatter’s camp in a plot to remove him from the election contest, and fought back by successfully bringing the FIFA president into the ethics case.

According to bin Hammam’s formal complaint, Blatter broke FIFA “duty of disclosure” rules because he was apparently aware via Warner that payments had been arranged and “had no issue.”

Warner dismissed suggestions that the evidence file compiled by John Collins, a former United States federal prosecutor who is now a member of FIFA’s legal committee, could end his career within football’s ruling body.

“I will hold my head high to the very end because I am not guilty of a single iota of wrongdoing. Qué será, será. I am not remotely bothered.”

Sunday, May 29, 2011

Dookeran steps down as COP leader

Winston Dookeran stepped down as Political leader of the Congress of the People (COP) Saturday, clearing the way for the party to elect his successor in its internal election on July 3.

JYOTI's sources say Dookeran was very emotional when he announced that he is giving up to party's top post but he did not endorse anyone for the leadership.


The Finance Minister will retain his cabinet post and will continue to be the MP for Tunapuna. However, he will hand over the leadership when COP elects a new leader in July.

Two candidates have so far declared their intention to run - Sports Minister Anil Roberts and Vernon de Lima, the party's vice-chairman.

St. Augustine MP Prakash Ramadhar is considering a run for the leadership but up to now had been reluctant to oppose the party's founding leader.

Like Dookeran Ramadhar is a founding member of the party and one of COP's deputy political leaders. He is also a very strong supporter of the People's Partnership and was a driving force with Dookeran to form the coalition that won the 2010 general election.

Both Ramadhar and Dookeran are former members of the United National Congress (UNC). Dookeran led the UNC for a while but resigned and formed COP, which contested the 2007 general election.

Ramadhar told media recently that he would make his intention clear before the June 12 nomination day. "Rest assured that we have worked with this party since 2007 after which most people thought it would have disappeared and become a memory," he said.

"But we worked and built this party to where it is today and that the leadership of this party is a very important thing and not to be trivialised and therefore I will take my responsibility when it comes," he added.

When Roberts announced that he would run against Dookeran he said he wants to breathe new life back into COP, which he described as a party that is "dying" and "lost its way".

He said, "The COP must return to the principles espoused by the leader Winston Dookeran of new politics, of bottom up not top down...

"We have lost our way and right now within the next six weeks the Congress of the People will find its way back to its roots with all the people who believed in the vision of Winston Dookeran and we going back there."

He claimed that COP is not connecting with the people who bought into the party's vision of new politics.

"The party is dying because the loyal supporters are feeling that their voices are not being heard. We have to bring the people back in charge, the people are in charge," Roberts said.

He said a rejuvenated COP would help make the People's Partnership stronger and he rejected suggestions that the party has not been treated fairly within the Partnership Government.

"We cannot blame others, we must look within ourselves. We have not represented our people well," he insisted.

De Lima's campaign is different. As an "outsider" who is neither elected nor sits in cabinet, he believes that the leaders of the People's Partnership should not be in government.

Such a formula would change the whole structure of government and not allow the current Prime Minister to hold the post.

He has indicated that it may be necessary for the leaders of parties in the People’s Partnership to remain outside of the Cabinet in order to avoid being silenced by the rule of collective responsibility.

“We need to have leaders outside the Cabinet who are free to observe and speak on issues as they arise in order to guide the cohesiveness of the process and work out matters,” he said.

He said being in cabinet causes a leader to be “hamstrung, virtually hog-tied” by collective responsibility. He is also campaigning on the need for the partnership to formalise mechanisms for dialogue.

COP MPs pay tribute to Dookeran

Winston Dookeran's surprise announcement that he is stepping down from the leadership of the Congress of the People (COP) brought tears many of his supporters. Dookeran also wept.

At least three MPs elected under the COP banner last year praised their leader.

San Fernando West MP and Minister of Energy Carolyn Seepersad-Bachan:
"Mr Dookeran has played and will continue to play a significant role in the politics of this country, but very important is whoever goes forward must ensure, and I think this is very important for this (COP) election that they be judged on how they want to take this party forward and continue the work of Mr Dookeran."

St. Augustine MP and Minister of Legal Affairs Prakash Ramadhar:
"He really was the guiding light that brought me into the politics, believing there is a space for young people in the politics, and he has proved today the highest expectation of the politics of the future: a leader standing down. He did not have to because he is loved tremendously."

Dr Lincoln Douglas, MP Lopinot/Bon Air West Minister of State in the Ministry of the People and Social Development:

"We live in a time where we have seen a history of political leaders, both nationally and internationally, who don't know when to leave or when to stop and have ended up seriously wounding themselves as change agents,

"I think Mr Dookeran's bigness of heart and the quality of his character and the content of his wisdom was demonstrated today by the offerings that he made of resigning from the leadership of the party."

Column: Dookeran helped change the T&T political paradigm

Winston Dookeran started his political career as a candidate for what was then the United Labour Front (ULF) in the 1981, winning the Chaguanas seat in the general election that year.

Prior to that he had been a lecturer at the Department of Economics at the University of the West Indies.

He was re-elected in 1986 as the Chaguanas MP as a candidate for the new National Alliance for Reconstruction (NAR), which was a unitary party that included the ULF and other parties opposed to the governing People's National Movement (PNM).

Basdeo Panday, who was one of the architects of the NAR, gave up the leadership of the new party to A.N.R. Robinson before the election. Once in government, Robinson named Dookeran as his Minister of Planning and Mobilization.

When the NAR broke up, Dookeran did not walk away with Panday and the former ULF politicians. He felt it was more constructive to remain in the NAR.

He later became Deputy Political Leader of the NAR and acted on several occasions as Prime Minister. During the 1990 attempted Muslimeen coup he was allowed to leave the Parliament to negotiate an end to the uprising.

Panday and his followers later formed the United National Congress (UNC) and in the 1991 general election Dookeran was defeated in Chaguanas by a candidate of the UNC.

He left politics and took a post as Senior Economist at the United Nations Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (UNECLAC). He was also a member of the Executive Board of the Inter-American Development Bank (IADB) and the governor of the Caribbean Development Bank (CDB).

In July 1997 the Panday government appointed Dookeran as Governor of the Central Bank of Trinidad and Tobago, a post he held until 2002 when Panday encouraged him to return to active politics.

Dookeran reluctantly agreed and won the St Augustine seat in the 2002 general election, which saw the PNM return to power.

The loss of the election created an opportunity for change in the UNC and in 2005 Dookeran was elected unopposed as leader of the UNC after Panday stepped aside and endorsed him. In that election Panday won the post of Chairman of the party.

From the start, Dookeran was at loggerheads with the UNC hierarchy and complained that Panday continued to influence party policy and undermine his authority as leader.

That created strong divisions, with one of his allies, Jack Warner, returning to join Panday to prepare for the 2007 general election. The writing was on the wall and Dookeran and some loyal UNC members, including Prakash Ramadhar and Anand Ramlogan, walked away and formed the Congress of the People (COP).

Within months, COP became a strong opposition party and the popular view leading up to the 2007 general election was that it would form the government. However, the UNC staged a strong comeback with Panday and Warner leading the party.

Although Dookeran's COP won 148,000 votes it failed to take a seat and the UNC returned as the official opposition with the PNM getting a strong majority.

Dookeran had campaigned on a new politics that offered integrity and accountability and attracted a mass of UNC supporters as well as the country's middle class.

Once the election was out of the way, Panday offered an olive branch of unity but Dookeran was reluctant. Although COP was interested in a united opposition, it did not want to do business with Panday, who had lost much of his political currency.

Warner, who had also become disenchanted with Panday's leadership, formed the Movement for Change and lobbied hard with some of parliamentary colleagues to have long overdue elections in the UNC. 


When Panday eventually agreed, Warner endorsed Kamla Persad-Bissessar and helped her win an unprecedented landslide in the UNC internal election on January 24, 2010.

That was the opportunity Dookeran sought. COP had always said it could do business with Persad-Bissessar and once she was in firm control of the UNC Dookeran made the next move, announcing publicly that the next election would be the opposition against the PNM.

Although COP was reluctant, Dookeran pushed ahead with his unity agenda and announced that he would join the opposition but not dissolve the party. That was the genesis of the unity that led to the Fyzabad Declaration and the formation of the People's Partnership, which defeated the PNM on may 24, 2010.

COP candidates won six of the seats in that election and Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar handed Dookeran the Finance Ministry.

Dookeran remained a strong supporter of the ideals of the Partnership and has expressed optimism that it will grow stronger. His departure from the leadership of the party does not change his or COP's commitment to the partnership. However that could change, depending on who emerges on July 3 as Dookeran's successor.

In an interview with JYOTI in November 2010 Dookeran had indicated that he would not contest the 2011 internal election. However he said he would always support the partnership because it is the best political formula for Trinidad and Tobago.

It was his commitment - and the dedication of Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar and other members of the partnership that led to the historic coalition of interests that today governs Trinidad and Tobago.



JAI PARASRAM

Energy minister warns against illegal trading in petroleum products

Energy Minister Carolyn Seepersad-Bachan called on citizens Saturday not to buy fuel from persons who have created a black market and are reselling the commodity.

She said apart from being illegal, this creates and health and safety hazard.

Several people have been hoarding fuel and some have been buying and reselling it since the shortage began one week ago. The minister said the shortage is due in part to the panic buying which is causing a higher than normal demand.

In a media release Saturday, the Minister noted the practice of gas-flogging is taking place at certain locations in South Trinidad.

She reminded citizens that the practice in illegal according to the Petroleum Act, which specifies that it is against the law for anyone to market petroleum products without a licence.

“In addition to the legal breaches, there is also the very important issue of the fact that selling fuel outside of the controlled conditions of the service station is a safety risk," she said. "These are highly flammable fuels and persons engaging in this gas-flogging are putting themselves and innocent citizens at very high risk,” the minister added.

Seepersad-Bachan again assured the country that Trinidad and Tobago through NP and the Bond at Pointe-a-Pierre has enough liquid fuels to service the needs of the motoring public. She said supply and distribution continues to be regular and there is no need for panic-buying.

CEPEP created 11,000 jobs in less than a year: Moonilal

Roodal Moonilal told the House of Representatives there was a history of nepotism and unlawful activity in the Environmental Protection and Enhancement Programme (CEPEP) under the former Manning PNM administration.

And he said this is the reason why the People's Partnership government has dismissed 47 CEPEP contractors.

The Housing Minister, whose portfolio includes CEPEP, said the former government allowed CEPEP to operate without transparency and accountability. 

Moonilal was responding to a question from opposition MP Donna Cox who wanted to know why the government's action has forced 2,500 people to be out of work.

The minister said, “Many of the contractors were involved in crime while others were friends and families who got contracts. Imagine, even General Council members (of the PNM) got CEPEP contracts."  

Moonilal noted that when the previous government started the programme it was designed for three years. "It was never agreed for contractors to be employed for eight years. Some areas in T&T do not even know what a CEPEP shirt looks like.”

The minister told legislators that from May 2011 to the present time, CEPEP created 11,000 people. He explained that one initiative was the establishment of an Unemployment Bureau in Chaguanas that has been able to identify unemployed citizens. 

He added that CEPEP would be working closely with the Ministry of Science and Tertiary Education to enrol skilled workers with the On The Job Training programme. 

He also said CEPEP will soon be launching a marine programme to maintain beaches and rivers throughout the country.

Look to India for political, economic lessons: Dookeran

The concept of a new partnership in the continuous development of the nation-state of Trinidad and Tobago must be forged with all members of the national citizenry as we celebrate the 166th anniversary of Indian Arrival Day, Monday May 30, 2011.

In developing our society, occasions such as Indian Arrival Day, Emancipation Day, Spiritual Shouter Baptist Liberation Day, Eid Ul Fitr and others, must not be celebrated in isolation, rather be viewed as each other’s opportunity to revalidate our patriotism. As citizens, our focus must be to create a modern state spurred within the perimeters of civic responsibility and good governance.

It is 166 years since our arrival from principally, Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, in India. 147 thousand originally made the journey across the Kala Pani. The past is over. 


Even though we may reflect on it, our energies should be directed towards the enactment of a new society, one whose people were sourced from Asia, Africa, Europe and the Middle East. The challenge facing our country, the Caribbean, and even beyond is how each sector of the populace shapes this new society.

Change is inevitable.

What matters is creating a balance where each citizen not only contributes to the change but feels that he or she has benefited as a consequence of change. 

The Indian Diaspora must therefore move forward accepting the fruits of change and establishing targets to reach this new level of equilibrium. Additionally confronting us, not only the Indian Diaspora is the maintenance of our sanity against the backdrop of a faltering humanity in a world society which remains in turmoil in several areas of leadership and philosophy.

It is noteworthy that our first Prime Minister Dr Eric Williams, 50 years ago had called on the University for the study of the philosophy of people like Indian Nobel Laureate Rabindranath Tagore. 

I think it is still appropriate for us to ensure that the Chair we set up is structured in a way to approach the enquiry of truth. 

Truth must now be engaged in the Universities by establishing or using an existing Chair for the study of political philosophers like Tagore, Nehru and Gandhi as well as those from Africa, Asia, Europe and outside Europe.

We must continue in the noble philosophy of our grandparents and great grandparents whereby the inheritance we pass on to our children, will be be superior to the one we received. 

Not only in a personal sense, but in the sense of governance, politics, and our society at large. And by so doing, we will be able to engender a stronger aura of patriotism. 

It is both historical and philosophical, that the peoples of the east could come to the west, and live in such beautiful harmony whether we are Hindu, Christian or Muslim. This ideal is another reason why we must celebrate Indian Arrival Day, as one of Divine glorification.

Economic powerhouse India now stalks the international arena as a key player in several areas of world leadership. In this context especially as we approach 50 years of independence, we must look to India for lessons in political and economic philosophy, while at the same time India could learn from us in Trinidad and Tobago, in terms of our unique creativity, endurance and harmonious mode of living.

Happy Indian Arrival Day 2011 to all, and may God bless our nation.

Winston Dookeran | Political Leader, Congress of the People

Vindication - the Peter O'Connor column

I do not see that there is any other interpretation which any neutral observer can put upon the results of several opinion polls on the government’s performance after their first year in office.

The polls indicated that more people approve of the government’s overall performance than disapprove. People felt that the PP government had outperformed the PNM in many specific areas, including Crime, Education and the Ministry of Works portfolio: traffic, flooding, and the like.

But for me, the most significant data came from the following in the MFO poll: “Sixty four percent of the sample indicated that they respect Mrs. Persad-Bissessar….. but they said their perception was that only thirty four percent of the general public has respect for her”. 
Significantly, this data was published in the absence of the actual question the pollsters would have asked. What is demonstrated here is that people remain in support of Kamla and her government, in spite of the torrent of innuendo and attack from several quarters, but they believe, because of the torrent, that they who support are in the minority! 

This speaks volumes about the perceptions of ordinary folk in T&T. People who are going about their business while the remnants of the PNM, sections of the labour movement, and some of the media work hysterically to attack and pull down the government at every turn. 

The noise they create, without producing a single hint of suggestion to assist the government in improving peoples’ lives, is suggesting that that this government inherited an efficient, wealthy, honest society from the PNM. 

The reality, which the average person has acknowledged in the polls, is that the PNM demitted office leaving a mess of crime, flooding, dry taps, pathetic infrastructure, a betrayed labour movement, and a slew of tall, useless and unfinished buildings.

I accept that this government has reason to be criticized, and I have said so before. However, I cannot accept—and apparently neither can the majority of our citizens—that they deserve the constant stream of harassment and invective to which we have seen them subjected.

One newspaper, publishing the poll results, could not bring itself to say “well done, under very difficult conditions”. Instead they published a two-page spread, titled “The year in missteps”. However, how critical to our country were these “missteps”, and which, when exposed or discovered, were not corrected?

Did anyone ever compile a similar list after Manning’s first year in 2002? And why not? Little items like appointing his wife as a cabinet minister (never corrected); Handing over state lands to the Muslimeen (corrected after a cabinet revolt, for which Valley, Rahael, Beckles, Hinds, Seukeran and Eddie Hart were dumped in 2007); Abandoning the newly built Biche High School on spurious grounds, and refusing to publish the Inquiry Report he commissioned.

And what about Patrick Manning’s subsequent international jaunts on a private executive jet, which just happened to belong to Repsol, who was negotiating (along with other oil companies) a better tax regime for drilling here? 

Incidentally, the Integrity Commission ruled that those flights were not a breach of the Integrity in Public Life Act! But today’s PNM is claiming that Kamla’s brief stay at the home of a friend was a breach, a position apparently supported by the chairman of the Integrity Commission?

The pressure that this government is receiving from labour must be compared with the docile acquiescence of labour leaders to the PNM’s statement in a time of plenty that “increasing wages would be inflationary”. 

Instead of treating with local workers, the PNM spent all of our money on those ridiculous, unfinished buildings, and to add insult to injury, they brought in workers from China to build them. And all of this under the watch of Calder Hart’s acolyte, Trade Union Leader Michael Annisette, who is now bleating for local workers! We nice yes!

But clearly, the people are not being fooled. Despite the torrent of criticism, people realize that a difficult task is being undertaken, and slowly, the incompetence of the PNM is being overcome.

And yet many of us are asking the government to move on, and to stop defending themselves. We should be asking the attackers to lay off for a while, because if the government does not answer, people will then claim that the accusations are true.

We have a responsibility to our country, and this includes monitoring and criticizing our governments. But this responsibility does not extend into the constant unsupported harping which we are being forced to endure. 

It is time to join the mainstream now identified, to work for a better T&T and better governance from those whom we put there. 

And this must include analyzing the criticisms of the saboteurs instead of just publishing them as “fact”.

Guest column: PP puts emphasis on coalition of interests - by Dr Hamid Ghany

As the People’s Partnership celebrated their first anniversary in government last week, they had managed to overcome the prediction that some had made that they would not be able to last that long. 

The address by Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar highlighted the fact that the Government welcomed dissent and criticism from within its own ranks as a strength rather than as a weakness.
To this end, that line of argument suggested that the Government had its own built-in checks and balances and the potential for an opposition force to exist inside of the corridors of power was in place. 

This would of course have implications for the official Opposition as they would have to join the space already created by those in power who now had the capacity to criticise themselves. 

This political experiment that was created by the People’s Partnership on April 21, 2010, at Charlie King Junction in Fyzabad was cobbled together because of a different set of circumstances. A general election was not due until 2012, however, the former prime minister, Patrick Manning felt that one was necessary in 2010.

He announced at his party’s special convention on March 27, 2010, that he agreed with the opposition forces that there should be a general election and announced that screening in the PNM would begin on April 6 thereafter. The PNM was thrown into a full-scale election mode in the twinkling of an eye. The opposition forces had to respond immediately as Parliament was dissolved at midnight on April 8. 

None of the policy measures of the Manning administration leading up to all of this suggested that a general election would have been in the air. The 2009-10 budget that was presented in September 2009 did not resemble an election budget, the Property Tax and the Revenue Authority Bill were highly controversial and were really the kind of measures to be implemented at the mid-term of a government’s tenure and not on the eve of a general election.

All of this had to be defended on the PNM platform together with the allegations against Udecott and the church in the Heights of Guanapo. The PNM also had the Keith Rowley campaign that was operating inside of the official PNM campaign. 

The People’s Partnership capitalised on this split in the PNM and the negative publicity against the party to sweep into power. Their common goal was the removal of the PNM which they accomplished, but then came the task of governing. 

It has been something of a bumpy ride for the People’s Partnership during its first year in office as there has been some unfinished business in relation to getting all State boards appointed. The process has taken some time and therefore performance cannot be measured fully. 

Nevertheless, the glue that has held the Partnership together is the accommodative political behaviour of the leaders of the respective entities in the Partnership. If that accommodative behaviour dissipates, there will be problems for the Partnership.
Prime Minister Persad-Bissessar went to great lengths to emphasise that the Partnership is based on the philosophy of power-sharing and not on the philosophy of a single dominant, hegemonic party that will seek to capture power for itself alone.

That was a contrast against the PNM. At the moment, there is an issue within the PNM of the appearance of a two-leader phenomenon with the official political leader, Dr Keith Rowley, having to contend with the actions of the former political leader, Patrick Manning. 

This has helped the People’s Partnership in more recent times as the official opposition became divided in the Parliament on a vote on a motion brought by Manning and also in respect of Manning’s most recent political move which is his current walk from Port-of-Spain to San Fernando. Rowley has to decide whether he will join Manning’s walk or stay away.
The People’s Partnership operated on the basis of a proportional representation allocation of seats up front and responsibility was assigned to the various parties (UNC, COP, TOP) to handle the seats assigned to them in order to face down the PNM in one-on-one battles, rather than three-way battles. The strategy worked.

In government, the Partnership seemed to have moved from one crisis to another with apologies along the way for missteps. While this was a refreshing new approach to governing the country that diminished the level of arrogance that usually accompanied errors in the past, too many apologies could undermine the credibility of the Government. 

Prime Minister Persad-Bissessar has shown decisive leadership in the cases of Nizam Mohammed and Mary King which is to be contrasted with her faltering performance in the Reshmi Ramnarine affair that preceded these events. 

It appears that her next major act of leadership will be the much-anticipated “realignment” of Government portfolios that is on the horizon. Opposition MP, Colm Imbert gave the People’s Partnership a “C” grade for its performance after one year. If that can be used as a benchmark from the PNM, then perhaps the Government did not fail its first-year test.

The above column has been reproduced from the GUARDIAN newspaper with permission of the author.

Saturday, May 28, 2011

Jack heads to Switzerland to face FIFA's ethics committee; PP gov't stands behind him

Jack Warner appears before FIFA'a Ethic Committee in Zurich Sunday to deal with allegations of bribery made by a member of the world football body's executive committee.

He will appear before the committee and remain in Switzerland for the election of FIFA's president, which takes place on Wednesday. The government of Trinidad and Tobago is standing behind the Works and Transport Minister, saying no one has proved anything against Warner.

For his part, Warner has said if it becomes necessary he will quit his FIFA post and focus solely on serving Trinidad and Tobago as a cabinet minister and MP. However he was firm that he has "nothing to answer to.”

He added that people were making the allegations because of the elections. He reminded journalists that the same thing happened in the run-up to the 2002 elections.

The FIFA vice president said, "Let them go ahead I have no problem with that...I will hold my head high to the very end because I repeat here again totally I am not guilty of a single iota of wrongdoing.”

He also commented on an e-mail, which he said was simply a request for assistance for Haiti to get two big screens at a cost of more than $1 million to see the World Cup.

“What is wrong with that?” Warner asked. “A simple e-mail about Haiti to get some big screens, that make news, boy I am amazed.”

Warner predicted an imminent "a football bombshell". He said, "In the next couple days, you will see a football tsunami that will hit FIFA and the world and will shock you."

He added, "The time has come when I must stop playing dead. So you’ll see it, it’s coming, trust me it is coming by now and Monday.”

Warner is not perturbed about what might happen in Zurich. "They can do what they want, it does not bother me.”

He said he has become the target of all kinds of attacks. "FIFA has 24 persons on the executive committee, Europe has nine, if the other 15 people are crooks and thieves and no good and so on, how come England only got one vote?” Warner asked.

“Why is it the other people in Europe didn’t vote for England? And nobody wants to answer that question.

“Why is it Jack Warner is being held as the person who bring them down? So I am Mandrake then.

“The US is accusing me of not working hard enough for them. What more do you want me to do? I did for the US all I could have done."

He also said he is not about to retire. "I know when I propose to leave FIFA, but it won’t be on a walking stick or when I reach 75."

Jai & Sero

Jai & Sero

Our family at home in Toronto 2008

Our family at home in Toronto 2008
Amit, Heather, Fuzz, Aj, Jiv, Shiva, Rampa, Sero, Jai